Court Overturns Ban
On Canadian Cattle
BILLINGS, Mont. -- A federal judge overstated the potential harm of allowing limited shipments of Canadian cattle into the United States after mad cow disease was found in Canada, an appeals court panel concluded in documents released Monday.
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit ruled that U.S. District Judge Richard F. Cebull erred in issuing a preliminary injunction that stalled a government plan to allow importation of cattle from Canada for the first time in more than two years.
"The record does not support the district court's alarmist findings that the 'irreparable economic harm' the district court foresaw from the stigma of Canadian beef will actually befall the American beef industry," the panel wrote.
The judges had overturned the injunction on July 14 in a brief order that allowed shipments to resume, but they did not release the 54-page opinion outlining their reasons until yesterday.
The United States banned Canadian cattle in May 2003 after Canada's first case of mad cow disease. Since then, authorities have found two cases in Canada and two in the United States. One of the U.S. cows was Canadian-born, the other was in Texas.
The United States was set to lift the ban in March when Cebull granted the injunction to a ranchers' group called R-CALF, United Stockgrowers of America, which argued that trade with Canada would pose a threat to U.S. consumers and cattle producers.
* BOSTON -- Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney (R) vetoed a bill expanding access to emergency contraception, angering abortion rights advocates while pleasing antiabortion activists crucial to a 2008 presidential run. Romney said the "morning-after pill" is already widely available without a mandate from the state. His veto may not stand because lawmakers passed the measure by veto-proof margins.
* SEATTLE -- The man convicted of plotting to blow up the Los Angeles airport on the eve of the millennium has refused to resume cooperating with the government, his lawyers acknowledged in a court filing. That means Ahmed Ressam's sentencing will proceed as scheduled Wednesday and he probably will receive a longer sentence. The U.S. attorney's office said that without Ressam's continued cooperation, the prosecution of two co-conspirators will be jeopardized.
* LINCOLN, Neb. -- Union Pacific Railroad discriminated against women by not covering contraceptives in its health care plan, a federal judge ruled in a class-action lawsuit that claimed the company discriminated by providing a range of health benefits -- including impotence drugs -- but no contraceptive care. Union Pacific spokesman Mark Davis said the decision to exclude contraceptives was negotiated with the company's unions.
* DENVER -- Hispanic and Muslim groups called on Rep. Tom Tancredo (R-Colo.) to resign, saying he has embarrassed Colorado with his anti-immigration stance and by suggesting that Americans bomb Islamic holy sites if terrorists launch a nuclear attack on the United States. Abdur-Rahim Ali, imam of a Denver Islamic center, said Tancredo's statement was unacceptable. "What would happen if a prominent Muslim made that statement about Catholic holy places like the Vatican?" Ali asked.
-- From News Services