The old and the new collide this season on Broadway. The question is whether it will be a complete disaster or the first step toward a well-reasoned rebuilding plan.

Representing the NFL's old guard are Coach Tom Coughlin and quarterback Kurt Warner. Both forged their reputations with other teams. Each knows the effort involved in advancing far into the playoffs, and in Warner's case, the necessary measures to win a Super Bowl.

The fresh face is Eli Manning, who had better get used to New York fans in a hurry. It might not be pretty at Giants Stadium if he does not live up to his billing as franchise savior.

Manning, however, will get some time to learn. Coughlin named Warner the starting quarterback after one particularly poor performance by Manning in the preseason in which he had a rating of 0.0.

The Giants traditionally have emphasized running the ball, and in that department, the team has contrasting options.

The starter is Tiki Barber, who ran for 1,216 yards last season and caught a team-high 69 passes for 461 yards. The polar opposite to Barber's darting style is Ron Dayne, the 1999 Heisman Trophy winner who came into camp leaner and more resolute in what may be his final opportunity with the team.

Reliable Michael Strahan anchors a defense that toiled last season and has revamped at linebacker with the departures of Mike Barrow, Dhani Jones and Brandon Short. Carlos Emmons is the most experienced of the bunch.

Keep an eye on the player-coach relationship this season. It didn't take long for a fissure to develop during one of the team's first minicamps, when players complained Coughlin worked them too hard.

"It's a tough game, and it's played by tough people," Coughlin said. "I think what we have to do is to reestablish the line of scrimmage on both sides of the ball. We have to be a smart football team."

Best Hands: Phil McConkey symbolized the opportunistic mind-set of Bill Parcells's Giants when he caught a deflected ball in the end zone for a touchdown that all but sealed Super Bowl XXI.

Worst Hands: Jeremy Shockey's drop of a sure touchdown cost the Giants in their 39-38 playoff loss to San Francisco in January 2003. Even worse, he taunted the 49ers after his second catch of the game and threw ice water in the direction of hecklers.

Grading This Year's WRs: Amani Toomer has had five straight seasons of at least 1,000 yards. Ike Hilliard must stay healthy for the passing game to work efficiently.

WRs grade: B