Capitals goalie Tomas Vokoun stops a shot as Washington defeats the Bruins, 5-3, on Jan. 24 at Verizon Center. (John McDonnell/THE WASHINGTON POST)

But with five games remaining in the regular season and a trip to the postseason on the line, the Capitals don’t have the luxury of a clear-cut top goaltender. Instead, they have a three-headed monster, with veteran Tomas Vokoun, 24-year-old Michal Neuvirth and 22-year-old rookie Braden Holtby.

Over the 14 games in March, Washington has used all three but none has established consistency and a rhythm over the course of successive games. A strong performance one night hasn’t guaranteed one the next and there’s little reason to believe one netminder holds a secure advantage over any other for the chance to play in these remaining contests.

Coach Dale Hunter doesn’t look at having three goaltenders with no go-to guy as a bad thing for the Capitals.

“When you have three,” Hunter said. “It’s better than having no goalies ready to play. This way I have three goalies that did well and now it’s up to me to make the right call for who I put in.”

Who will Hunter opt to start in the critical contest against the Bruins? Everyone will have to wait – possibly until warm-ups on Thursday evening at TD Garden – to find out.

Here’s a look at the options and how they’ve fared in March:

(Jonathan Newton/WASHINGTON POST)

In those three starts, Vokoun is 2-1, having allowed eight goals on 87 shots for a .908 save percentage and 2.62 goals-against average. Now that he’s healthy, Vokoun wants the opportunity to lead the Capitals when the games matter most, though.

“You look at it where we are,” Vokoun said. “It’s a lot riding on the season for me, too, so there’s nothing to save anything for. Whatever happens, happens. I play, I’m gonna try and help the team win the game.”

(Jonathan Newton/WASHINGTON POST)

The uncertainty down the stretch doesn’t bother Neuvirth too much though. “I got kind of used to it,” he said. “You never know. It is what it is. It’s not my decision and that’s why we’ve got a coach.”


Is the blame for the 5-1 defeat solely on Holtby? No, but his style is one Hunter likes to call risk-reward, and against Buffalo the emphasis was on risk.

In his four games this month, Holtby is 2-1-0 with a .934 save percentage and 2.02 goals against average.

More on the Capitals:
Wise: Does Hunter know how to motivate?
Hunter gives Capitals the day off
On Hockey: Caps blow another big game