Bob Schaeffer of FairTest, the nonprofit organization that monitors U.S. testing very closely, says this is not what is happening. U.S. News checked its data and found no advantage for test-optional schools. He says there are many ways colleges can pad their scores, such as not reporting athletes or students who enroll in spring or summer. I tend to agree with Schaeffer. I don't think any of these games make much of a difference in college rankings. But what do you think? What are Schaeffer and I missing?