After a June kitchen fire shuttered it for nearly four months, the taxidermy-friendly Capitol Hill bar has restored almost all of its celebrated decorations, but diehard fans will notice a few differences.
“We saved all of the memorabilia with the exception of my granddad’s two deer [rumps], which were over the ladies’ room door,” says Nardelli.
Much of the restaurant’s interior -- old beer signs, black and white photos, the animal heads -- suffered smoke or water damage, Nardelli says, adding that she had “a $10,000 bill at the taxidermist” to freshen up the decor. Smoke also got into the plaster panels of the drop ceiling. When it was removed, it exposed a much higher ceiling surrounded by exposed brick -- a relic from the building’s earlier days as a tailor shop -- and a skylight, making the one-room bar feel airier and brighter.
Among the other additions: New dark wood paneling “like it was when I was a kid,” says Nardelli, 37, the third-generation owner of the bar, and new retro-styled chrome-and-black-vinyl booths and barstools. The gleaming bar counter and the original back bar look like new, thanks to a carpenter’s repairs.
But the changes go beyond the cosmetic.
The kitchen will still be turning out West Virginia-style favorites: patty melts, cheeseburgers, fried okra and the all-day breakfast. On weekdays, the stove will be manned by Eddie Peterson, formerly the chef at the Hawk and Dove next door, and one of six employees making their way over from that bar, which closed earlier this month for an extended makeover. “They were our neighbors for 44 years,” Nardelli explains. “[Peterson] is going to be making his specials Monday through Friday. But most of the menu is exactly the same” and the menus prices are the same, too, she says.
“We might look a little different, but we’ll feel the same.”
And that, she says, was the goal of the renovations. “I did it in a way I know my granddad and my dad would have liked.”