The Washington Post

The way West Virginia prices its bills is flawed, reports find


Fiscal notes, legislative analysis, cost estimates — call it what you want, but the official price tags attached to bills are a key part of legislating at every level of government.

Many states have dedicated legislative analysts, and virtually every state has at least some way of estimating the fiscal impact of proposed policies. But West Virginia’s methods may be seriously off the mark, according to a new report.

“When legislators or taxpayers need an estimate of how much new legislation will cost or save the state, the information they receive is often biased, inaccurate, incomplete or flawed,” writes Sean O’Leary, a policy analyst with the West Virginia Center on Budget and Policy and the report’s author.

West Virginia is one of a handful of states that asks the agencies affected by new policies to also analyze their fiscal impact, a system that O’Leary says opens up the analyses to bias and inaccuracies as agencies unfamiliar with making such analyses are tasked with conducting them. In a 1999 survey, the National Conference of State Legislatures found that just six of 40 states have such systems.

In one instance cited by O’Leary, a bill introduced this year that requires bulletproof vests for deputy sheriffs was determined to have a $0 fiscal impact. In the footnotes, however, it’s made clear that outfitting all the relevant personnel with vests could cost as much as $287,500, but the cost would be borne by counties, so technically, it would cost the state government nothing.

A pair of official state reports on fiscal 2007 and 2008 show how the system often fails to accurately assess the impact of policies. The report shows that the state’s fiscal estimates were close — within a 10 percent margin — just slightly more often than they were off by 50 percent or more. Fiscal note estimates were close about 13 percent of the time. The notes were way off about 10 percent of the time. And those results are based on self-reporting from the agencies that conducted the fiscal notes.

The West Virginia Center on Budget and Policy found little confidence in the notes among 43 lawmakers who responded to a survey question. Nearly half of Democrats believed the notes were accurate less than half the time or never, with about three in five Republicans saying the same. The same held true when asked whether they felt the fiscal notes were prepared objectively.

Reliable estimates are key to good legislating, O’Leary argues. Without them, it’s impossible to make smart fiscal decisions. “Improving the fiscal note process should be a priority,” he writes.

Niraj Chokshi is a general assignment reporter for The Washington Post.

The Freddie Gray case

Please provide a valid email address.

You’re all set!

Campaign 2016 Email Updates

Please provide a valid email address.

You’re all set!

Get Zika news by email

Please provide a valid email address.

You’re all set!
Show Comments
Republicans debate tonight. The South Carolina GOP primary and the Nevada Democratic caucuses are next on Feb. 20. Get caught up on the race.
Justice Scalia, in his own words
The Fix asks The State's political reporter where the most important region of the state is.
The State's Andy Shain says he could talk about Charleston, which represents a little bit of everything the state has to offer from evangelicals to libertarians, and where Ted Cruz is raising more money than anywhere else. In a twist, Marco Rubio is drawing strong financial support from more socially conservative Upstate. That said, Donald Trump is bursting all the conventional wisdom in the state. So maybe the better answer to this question is, "Wherever Trump is."
Past South Carolina GOP primary winners
South Carolina polling averages
Donald Trump leads in the first state in the South to vote, where he faces rivals Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio.
South Carolina polling averages
The S.C. Democratic primary is Feb. 27. Clinton has a significant lead in the state, whose primary falls one week after the party's Nevada caucuses.
62% 33%
The complicated upcoming voting schedule
Feb. 20

Democrats caucus in Nevada; Republicans hold a primary in South Carolina.

Feb. 23

Republicans caucus in Nevada.

Feb. 27

Democrats hold a primary in South Carolina.

Upcoming debates
Feb 13: GOP debate

on CBS News, in South Carolina

Feb. 25: GOP debate

on CNN, in Houston, Texas

March 3: GOP debate

on Fox News, in Detroit, Mich.

Campaign 2016
Where the race stands

To keep reading, please enter your email address.

You’ll also receive from The Washington Post:
  • A free 6-week digital subscription
  • Our daily newsletter in your inbox

Please enter a valid email address

I have read and agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Please indicate agreement.

Thank you.

Check your inbox. We’ve sent an email explaining how to set up an account and activate your free digital subscription.