This should have a familiar ring if you have any memory of what happened the last time there was a Republican in the White House. In fact, this is pretty much the standard Republican spending playbook, which goes like this:
- Increase military spending.
- Cut back the agencies that might inconvenience big business or Wall Street.
- Attack programs that help the poor.
- Cut taxes for the wealthy.
- Try to go after Medicare and Social Security, then get skittish when the political risk becomes apparent and abandon the effort.
As we know from George W. Bush’s tenure, this formula produces an explosion of economic growth, raising wages and bringing prosperity to all while reducing the deficit. Right?
There are a few things missing from the budget blueprint, but which we’ve gotten indications of elsewhere. Republicans are eager to slash Medicaid, by ending its guarantee of health coverage for the poor and transforming it into a block-grant program that would be funded at lower levels and give states the “flexibility” to toss people off their health coverage whenever they’d rather use the money for something else. That’s supposed to be part of the repeal of the Affordable Care Act, which they still can’t figure out how to do — and it’s being complicated by the fact that a lot of Republican governors and Republican voters benefited greatly from the ACA’s Medicaid expansion. There will be some kind of huge tax cut for the wealthy (absolutely nothing is more important for Republicans), but the details of that reform are still being worked out. This budget won’t yet address Social Security, which many Republicans would like simply to cut, or Medicare, which they’d like to privatize (and then cut). If history is any guide, they’ll begin talking about how they want to “strengthen” those programs, then become utterly spooked when elderly constituents show up at the offices of their members of Congress telling them to keep those grubby hands off their beloved Social Security and Medicare.
But the overall picture is remarkably similar to what we’ve seen before. That infrastructure plan Trump promised doesn’t seem to be there, for instance. And we know that the deficit will balloon under their plans, because we’ve seen that before, too — a bunch of people who call themselves “deficit hawks” are interested only in cutting the programs they never liked in the first place and end up increasing the deficit massively to pay for their beloved tax cuts.
In fact, if you were one of those downtrodden, white, working-class voters who supposedly delivered Trump his electoral college victory, you might be asking what happened to all that winning you were promised. Wasn’t Trump supposed to be something different, not like every other Republican?
He’s different all right, just not in the way those voters may have been hoping. Because when it comes to boring policy stuff such as the federal budget, Trump winds up being just like every other Republican, whether because it’s what he really wants or because he doesn’t much care and other people are handling it. But those are the things that actually wind up affecting people’s lives.