John Boehner

The House Republicans have responded to the president’s offer with essentially the “grand bargain” proposed in the summer of 2011. (This is only fitting since the president essentially gave Democrats his past budget proposal.)

House Speaker John Boehner said in a statement:

In a letter sent to President Obama today, House Republican leaders made a new offer to avert the fiscal cliff centered around a middle ground approach first presented to Congress last year by President Clinton’s former White House chief of staff, Erskine Bowles. The Bowles plan, presented in 2011 to the Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction, is consistent with the framework House Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) proposed the day after the election: a balanced approach of significant spending cuts and new revenues from tax reform with fewer loopholes and lower tax rates. This is another attempt to jumpstart substantive, good faith negotiations toward a bipartisan solution that can be enacted soon, a stark contrast to the unserious proposal the White House put forward last week.

 In a document obtained by Right Turn from House Republicans, the plans match up as follows:

President’s Deficit Reduction

Tax Rates Increases:              $960B

Elimination of Deductions:      $600B

Spending Cuts:                         $400B


New Stimulus/Other

Infrastructure Spending:          -$95-425B

Payroll Tax Extension:            -$110B

Unemployment Insurance:      -$30B

Stimulus Tax Extenders:         -$27B

Unpaid for SGR Patch:            -$25B

Mortgage Plan:                        Unknown

Elimination of Debt Limit:                N/A

NET SAVINGS:          (At most) $1.673T


House Republican Counter

(Based on the Bowles Proposal to the Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction)

Deficit Reduction

Revenue through Tax Reform:       $800B

Health Savings:                               $600B

Other Mandatory Savings:             $300B

Revision to CPI:                              $200B

Further Discretionary Savings:     $300B

NET SAVINGS:                             $2.2T

A House leadership aide told Right Turn that “the GOP offer includes more deficit reduction than the White House offer last week, which included hundreds of billions in new ‘stimulus’ spending. Our net deficit reduction is $2.2 trillion, but if we were to utilize White House schemes to count (1) previously-enacted Budget Control Act savings, (2) a war savings gimmick, and (3) further interest savings, our proposal would result in $4.6 trillion in deficit reduction savings, much more than theirs.”

So we have the potential for a deal that is somewhere between Bowles’s plan last year and the president’s plan. It is not, however, a matter of simply total savings. The Republicans have included far less revenue, as well as less revenue to be obtained through tax reform. The Democrats have yet to present a substantive offer that looks at systemic entitlement reform. The Republicans have shown that, contrary to the liberal-media meme, Boehner and not Grover Norquist controls the House. (And we expect this is not even the final GOP offer, leaving room for more revenue perhaps.)

We are far from a deal. We’re not close, but we are no longer “nowhere.” Your turn, Mr. President.

More from The Washington Post:

Charles Krauthammer: Cliff-jumping with Obama

Jonathan Bernstein: Boehner’s proposal is a start, but is it serious?

Marc Thiessen: ‘Fiscal cliff’ will be disaster for Democrats

Greg Sargent: John Boehner’s exit strategy

Robert Samuelson: The left’s bad-faith bargaining