The Washington Post

Mountaintop’s MLK: too much fiction?

Samuel L. Jackson and Angela Bassett in a scene from "The Mountaintop" by Katori Hall. (Courtesy of O&M Co.) (Joan Marcus/©2011 JOAN MARCUS)

That quality of the humanness of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., portrayed by Jackson, was the central message of the play Mountaintopin an imaginary scene in Room 306 in a Memphis motel, where he encounters a mysterious angelic maid (Angela Bassett).

In real life, that motel is where King returned after delivering a powerful prophetic sermon proclaiming that, like Moses, he may not get to the Promised Land with his followers but he certainly had looked over and viewed it from the Mountaintop.

In the play, Dr. King wrestled with real fears and agonized over mistakes and imperfections, helped or maybe hindered in his efforts by the spellbinding maid, Camae.

 Before attending the play, I shuttered at what boundaries the play might cross in dealing with a modern flesh and blood man, who is also carved in stone on the National Mall. There is a thin line between fiction and reality when dealing with people versus icons. An expressed goal of the 30-year-old Mountaintop playwright Katori Hall was to reach for the “human touch.”

 I have seen those words become a cover to set the stage for exploitative money-grabbing sensationalism. I believe that was the motivation behind the close encounters Ralph Abernathy said he witnessed between Dr. King and women in the Memphis motel on the eve of King’s death in Abernathy’s autobiography And The Walls Came Tumbling Down.” Family members and staff said the depiction was false.

 Mountaintop made great leaps of the imagination as it compressed many acts—real or made-up-- into a single night. The next morning, April 4, 1968, changed history as King was assassinated..

In Mountaintop, audiences saw scenes showing a Dr. King that some close relatives-- who did not want to be quoted-- did not recognize or would not validate. One scene showed King chain smoking a Pall Mall, sharing a drink from a flask with the maid/angel Camae, where both in a fit of glee exclaimed “F...the White man.”

A smoking, drinking, cussing Dr. King? Heaven forbid. Is some fiction just a guise for negative re-invention?  In watching the play, I kept telling myself this is fiction. This is imaginary. Blending of reality with fiction is what theater does. “Chill,” I told myself. Besides, the audience loved it; the actors were incredibly brilliant. 

“The minute Dr. King comes on stages and uses the toilet, you know we are talking about a real person not an icon,” Jackson said. “In fact I try to be that kind of real person, riding the subway for example.”

But with a big smile he said, “Fame does help, however, when you are trying to get a good seat in a top restaurant.”

That shouldn’t be a problem for Jackson. His résumé includes more than 100 films, yielding nearly $7.5 billion for Hollywood, making him about the highest-grossing actor of all time, according to the Guinness Book of World Records.

Angela Bassett, one of the nation’s most gifted actresses, whose credits include portraying Tina Turner in “What Has Love Got to Do With It,” is deserving of a Tony Award for her incredibly flawless portrayal of Camae who helps Dr. King come to grips with the bullet awaiting him just outside the motel balcony.  She is flawless as she pours out a flurry of words in a power-packed soliloquy about the steps ahead in the fight for civil rights. 

Equally remarkable is that the play, which debuted in London last year, was written by 30-year-old African-American playwright Katori Hall. A graduate of Columbia University and the Juilliard School, she has won scores of honors, including the Lorraine Hansberry Playwriting award.

At the end Jackson delivers memorable lines challenging the audiences to pass the baton to continue the fight for human rights after which film clips roll of King’s life retracing his greatness as a leader/savior/martyr. That Dr. King was one of the greatest public figures of our age and “just a man,” makes his life easier for everyday folks to emulate he said.

Was Mountaintop too much fiction?  Is it easier to follow in the footsteps of a man who makes very human mistakes, even if they may be fictionalized? Go see for yourself. It is set to end on January 22 when Jackson exits to start filming for Django Unchained, directed by Quentin Tarantino.

Read more on The Root DC

Fuqua’s racist legacy remains?

Oprah’s network may cater to African Americans

Reynolds is an ordained minister and the author of six books, including the first unauthorized biography of the Rev. Jesse Jackson. She is a former editor and columnist for USA Today.



Success! Check your inbox for details. You might also like:

Please enter a valid email address

See all newsletters

Show Comments
Most Read



Success! Check your inbox for details.

See all newsletters