One of the questions I often get from parents is whether they should give their children an allowance. My answer: It depends.
Creditcards.com released a survey recently that found just 40 percent of parents with children under 18 give them an allowance.
Last week I asked: Did getting an allowance as a child help you become a better money manager?
James Pritchett from Austin wrote, “We were poor and I received no allowance and never expected one. I did receive a dime from my aunt for every “A” I got in elementary school. I worked as a teenager and all through college. Saving was a goal even then and has continued all through my life.”
“Getting an allowance as a child made me a better money manager, but for all the wrong reasons,” wrote Chuck Anderson of Chesapeake, Va. “I was the oldest child and was given an allowance of $5 a week (1962-68) to cook for my two siblings and watch them and for minor house cleaning. Problem was my parents could never afford to pay it, so it just kept adding up. When it got high enough they would ask me what I wanted and they would then buy it on their credit card, which they did not pay off in full. What I learned: Don’t promise funds you don’t have, and don’t buy anything you can’t pay for in full, especially when you put it on a credit card. As a result I was able to retire with enough money in the bank to have a comfortable retirement.”
“I received an allowance from the time I was two or three years old until I got my first job at age 16,” wrote Jean L. Potuchek from Poland, Maine. “I do think the allowance experience made me a better money manager, in two ways. First was the lesson of trade-offs and deferred gratification. My first allowance — this was in the 1950s — was two cents per week. I mostly spent this at the little corner store across the street from our apartment. I could get two pieces of penny candy, or I could get four pieces if I chose the candies that were two for a penny. I think I occasionally managed the feat of saving for three weeks (a very long time for a preschooler!) to savor the delicious indulgence of a 5-cent chocolate ice cream cone. More important, though, was the way our allowances were dispensed. Each Thursday evening, my father would stop on the way home from his factory job to cash his paycheck. After supper, he would sit down at the dining room table and go through the process of dividing that cash among the budget envelopes that were designated for items such as rent, electricity, telephone, groceries, and insurance payments. As the last step in this process, little piles of coins were placed at the edge of the table for children’s allowances. Because this happened last, we children were all glued to the entire process and all grew up with a good understanding of budgeting. I have been a lifelong budgeter, and I credit my allowance and the budgeting lessons that went with it for my ability to successfully manage my personal finances.”
Steve Shafer of Wake Forest, N.C., wrote, “My parents gave allowances to my brother and me when we reached late elementary school age in the 1960s, starting at 50 cents per week and going up a bit each year (to around a dollar or a little more) until we each got after-school jobs in high school (brother in a grocery store, me in the public library). There were strings attached to the allowance. We had to do any chore my parents assigned, after being told to do so only once, and with no complaining. On Saturdays, when dad paid the allowances, we had to be present when mom gave the performance appraisals. If during the week she had to nag us to do something, or we had griped about it, then dad reduced the pay, usually by a dime per incident. My parents never told us specifics on how to spend our money. They occasionally asked if we thought something really was a good use of our money, but the decision was ours. They did say that the choices we made for our money reflected on our character. Today, my wife and I am retired. We live “beneath our means,” but we have zero debt, have a solid emergency fund, we travel now and then, give to several charities, support the educational savings for our little great-nieces, and enjoy our music hobbies. Wife asks me to do chores occasionally, and I try to do them the first time, without griping. Life feels secure for now, which is our retirement goal. Thanks, Mom and Dad.”
In all these stories, whether they got an allowance or not, what really mattered was what the parents did and didn’t say.
The Creditcards.com survey also found that 1 in 4 Americans said their parents didn’t provide them with any financial education.
Color of Money Question of the Week
What do you wish your parents had taught you about money? Send your comments to firstname.lastname@example.org. Please include your name, city and state. In the subject line, put “What I Wish I Had Been Taught.”
I’m back. Join me live at noon (Eastern time) today. I'll be taking your personal finance questions.
It’s also “Testimony Thursday.” Share your financial success stories. Have you paid off debt? Do you finally have an emergency fund?
You can join the discussion by clicking this link.
Also, if you are new to the chat you will notice that to join the discussion you’ll have to sign into your Washington Post account or create one. All the live chats now have a “registration wall.” Here’s a FAQ that may address your concerns.
Q: Why do I have to create a Post account to join the live chat?
We value your readership and we want to deepen that tie. Making a free account on washingtonpost.com gives you access to things you can’t get otherwise, such as newsletters like this one.
Q: Does the account mean I’ll be charged a subscription to The Post?
No, a subscription is separate from having a Washington Post account. With a Washington Post account, there will still be a monthly paywall, but you’ll be able to manage your newsletters and edit preferences for The Post.
Q: Are questions submitted to live chats still anonymous?
Yes, your Washington Post account is not connected to live chat submissions.
Q: I’m having technical issues with the registration wall. Who do I contact to fix that?
If you are having a technical issue signing up for the free account, contact customer service and they can help troubleshoot the issue: https://help.washingtonpost.com
Color of Money Columns This Week
Knowledge isn’t power. The right knowledge is power.
Stay informed about your money.
In addition to this newsletter, please read and share my weekly personal finance columns.
Newsletter Comments Policy
Please note it is my personal policy to identify readers who respond to questions I ask in my newsletters. I find it encourages thoughtful and civil conversation. I want my newsletters to be a safe place to express your opinion. On sensitive matters or upon request, I’m happy to include just your first name and/or last initial. But I prefer not to post anonymous comments. (I do make exceptions when I’m asking questions that might reveal sensitive information or cause conflict.)
Have a question about your finances? Michelle Singletary has a weekly live chat every Thursday at noon where she discusses financial dilemmas with readers. You can also write to Michelle directly by sending an email to email@example.com. Personal responses may not be possible, and comments or questions may be used in a future column, with the writer’s name, unless otherwise requested.
To read more Color of Money columns, go here.
If you’re viewing this post online, sign up to automatically receive Michelle Singletary’s newsletters right into your email box: “Your Retirement” on Mondays and “Personal Finance” on Thursdays.