The economic and social crisis that’s driving support for Italy’s hard right ahead of the Sept. 25 elections is making the euro zone’s third-largest economy vulnerable to even deeper infiltration by organized crime.
Draghi’s immediate concern was the risk to the 260 billion euros ($261 billion) of European Union recovery funds programmed for Italy by 2026. While mobsters found new ways of making money during the pandemic -- muscling in on mask production and funeral services -- the EU cash offers a fat new target.
As Europe faces the bleak winter of a conjoined economic and energy crisis, police officials and crime experts are sounding a new alarm about mafia groups acquiring businesses at risk of default. It’s a problem across southern Europe, but Italy is at particular risk as small and midsized firms make up some 80% of the economy. Criminal ownership of business is a nightmare scenario that would undermine the legitimate economy, distorting competition, rule of law, and the social fabric. Worse, it’s already happening.
Milan Police Commissioner Giuseppe Petronzi recently warned of “a military operation” by the southern mafia to infiltrate the north, one of Europe’s wealthiest regions. Recent data suggests that’s not an exaggeration. Italy saw a 9.7 rise in the number of companies investigated by the financial police due to suspected mafia activity between March 2020 and February 2021, the latest data available, according to Vittorio Rizzi, the nation’s deputy director general of public security. The Rome-based research group Demoskopika has estimated some 4,500 firms were at risk of mafia infiltration after the Covid-19 crisis, especially those in tourism and restaurants and bars.
The risk Italy faces now is a proliferation of what the United Nations Office for Drugs and Crime calls “the mafia entrepreneur.” Italy was the first country where this role was identified more than a decade ago. Specifically, “the mafia entrepreneur” typically involves an adherent to an organized crime group -- with identities concealed by a shell company — taking a minority stake and effective control of a legitimate business. I recently asked Michele Riccardi, deputy director and senior researcher at Transcrime, a Milan research center on transnational crime, how bad he thought mafia infiltration of Italian business could get. “I cannot imagine it being any worse than it is,” he responded glumly.
The cost falls on everyone because the commercial dysfunction wrought by the mafia can substantially reduce per capita GDP growth, according to a study published in August by a trio of Bank of Italy economists.
How then can organized crime’s deeper penetration into legitimate commerce be confronted? Big data can lend a hand. Transcrime recently signed a three-year agreement with the financial police in Lombardy, the region around Milan, to use big data to track anomalous applications for post-pandemic funding, and oddities in the structure of company acquirers.
The hope is better computer-driven analysis will work faster than criminals can insinuate themselves into the corporate system. And cutting out human involvement can overcome other obstacles to detection too -- such as fear. One local entrepreneur in the Veneto region I spoke to described a rash of small family-owned firms going up for sale since the pandemic. “We know who is selling, but we have no idea who is buying. And sometimes it’s just better to mind your own business and not ask,” he said, asking not to be named.
Draghi called for community vigilance to defend the legitimate economy. That’s laudable. But Europe’s looming energy crisis could very well widen social divisions, creating the kind of fissures into which organized crime can crawl. Enrico Letta, leader of the Democratic Party, which is running second to Giorgia Meloni’s far-right Brothers of Italy, has warned of a coming “social and economic crisis” this winter. That’s only going to push more companies to the brink. It doesn’t help that Meloni’s campaign is fanning fears of a breakdown in law and order. Nor does it help that one of Meloni’s allies, the disgraced tycoon Silvio Berlusconi, has spent two decades denying allegations of mafia links.
Draghi is widely considered to have brought stability to Italy. A revival of concern about the rule of law is only going to make foreign companies even more reluctant about investing in a sluggish, debt-riddled economy. Depressingly, that may leave Italy more exposed to the infiltration of organized crime into the fabric of its industry and society.
More From Bloomberg Opinion:
• In Today’s Wars, Everything Can Be Weaponized: Max Hastings
• Italy’s Right Clings to the Past — and Falls Flat: Maria Tadeo
• Putin Wannabes Are a Growing Threat to Europe: Pankaj Mishra
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion
©2022 Bloomberg L.P.