Ten months after the story detailed the disquieting saga, federal prosecutors announced that they arrested Ray and charged the now-60-year-old with nine counts that include sex trafficking, extortion and forced labor, among numerous other charges.
Ray “allegedly used his proximity to his victims to lay the groundwork for psychological conditioning, eventually leading several young adults to become unwitting victims of sexual exploitation, verbal and physical abuse, extortion, forced labor, and an egregious case of prostitution,” FBI Assistant Director William F. Sweeney Jr. said in the announcement of the federal indictment.
When he was arrested Tuesday, authorities said, Ray was with one of the female victims identified in the indictment as well as one of his daughter’s college roommates.
The accusations that Ray manipulated several people over multiple years in part underlines the need for schools to warn students about what sex trafficking can look like on a college campus, one expert told The Washington Post.
“Sex trafficking has a much lower threshold than people realize,” Iliana Konidaris, founder of civil rights firm Konidaris Law, said in an interview. “When they hear the term, they think there must be a transportation element that involves women being imported from abroad. That it’s not something that happens on elite American college campuses.”
“College is supposed to be a time of self-discovery and newfound independence — a chance to explore and learn, all within the safety of a college community,” Geoffrey Berman, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, said Tuesday at a news conference. “The defendant exploited that vulnerable time in these victims’ lives through a course of conduct that shocks the conscience."
Prosecutors say Ray subjected victims he first met at the school in Yonkers, N.Y., to physical abuse and sexual and psychological manipulation over several years.
First while living in on-campus housing and then in a one-bedroom Manhattan apartment where some of the victims later also lived, Ray compelled some of them to participate in “therapy” sessions, according to the indictment. During these sessions, the indictment said, he squeezed out intimate details of their personal lives and lectured them on his own philosophies. He convinced several people they were “broken,” drawing out details of mental health struggles and saying he would help them, according to the indictment, which did not include the alleged victims’ names or ages. He also led interrogation sessions with multiple alleged victims present.
Prosecutors said Ray falsely accused his victims of damaging his property, of trying to harm or poison him, and extracted false confessions. After accusing one male victim of damaging his property, he wielded a knife and threatened to dismember him until that victim falsely confessed, according to the indictment.
To repay Ray for supposed harm and property damages, one female victim began working as a prostitute at Ray’s behest in 2014 through at least about 2018, authorities say. According to the indictment, he took the majority of her earnings, totaling more than half a million dollars.
Some alleged victims depleted their parents’ savings to repay supposed debts to Ray, the indictment reads. They opened lines of credit. They begged acquaintances for financial help.
“The conduct alleged here is outrageous; it makes you angry,” Sweeney said at the news conference. “If it doesn’t make you angry, you don’t have a soul.”
Ray faces a maximum sentence of life in prison.
In a statement, Sarah Lawrence College said the “charges contained in the indictment are serious, wide-ranging, disturbing, and upsetting.” The school said it has not been contacted by the Southern District of New York but is willing to cooperate with the investigation.
The college said after the New York magazine story was published, an internal investigation “did not substantiate those specific claims.”
Konidaris said the kind of exploitation alleged in the case can “happen in high schools and middle schools. It happens on college campuses — wherever there are power dynamics.”
She said that’s why schools must inform students about signs of sexual exploitation and sex trafficking that can affect male and female students, pointing to the “early grooming and recruiting” detailed in allegations against Ray.
In the magazine story, one male student recalled that Ray’s presence was not immediately questioned by the vulnerable youth. That student described struggling during the school year and receiving advice from Ray.
“I was directionless, and suddenly this ‘real man’ came into my life,” he told the publication. “It was this incredible feeling of such intense validation, of being seen and heard finally.”
Konidaris told The Post that having explicit policies in place may also help students come forward.
“How do you explain the situation to a college administrator in a beautiful, pristine office? It’s a big ask,” she said. “If you at least put it in your policies, establish the definition, tell students you’re trained to understand the signs, put it in your resources list — that would be huge.”