President Trump’s school safety commission, formed after the Feb. 14 mass shooting at a Florida high school and chaired by Education Secretary Betsy DeVos, has just released its recommendations on how to make schools safer — and one North Carolina educator isn’t impressed.
The commission’s 177-page report that Trump and DeVos released Tuesday recommends a number of ways authorities can secure schools, including considering arming personnel. It advised against increasing the minimum age required for gun purchases.
The report called for more mental health services for students but didn’t offer new federal funding. And it gives notice that the Trump administration will rescind an Obama-era effort to reduce racial disparities in school discipline.
Justin Parmenter, who teaches seventh-grade language arts at Waddell Language Academy in Charlotte, wrote the following letter to DeVos about his reaction to the report.
Parmenter, an educator for more than 20 years, started his teaching career “believing that I was going to transform every child,” just as many first-year teachers do when they are placed in schools with high-needs populations. He says he quickly learned how complex teaching is.
Parmenter is a fellow with Hope Street Group’s North Carolina Teacher Voice Network. He started his career as a Peace Corps volunteer in Albania and taught in Istanbul. He was a finalist for Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools teacher of the year in 2016, and you can find him on Twitter here.
Here is Parmenter’s open letter to DeVos:
Dear Secretary DeVos,
Last month, my 7th-grade students and I huddled on the floor of my classroom during yet another lockdown. As the minutes ticked slowly past, I made eye contact with each student, one by one. I could see on their faces the absolute trust that I would guide them through whatever challenges we faced.
In the wake of the horrific gun deaths of 17 people at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, last Valentine’s Day, the White House convened a school safety commission with you at the helm. The Federal Commission on School Safety’s task was a really important one: to find ways to keep us safer in our schools.
While your commission deliberated, the public did too. Here’s what we came up with:
Teachers said they don’t want to carry guns.
Parents said they don’t want teachers to carry guns.
Teens said they don’t want teachers to carry guns.
Notice a trend?
Educators did have some alternative suggestions, which we offered at every possible opportunity. We asked for stricter firearms laws, including raising the age limit for gun purchases. We wanted access to the military-style assault weapons so frequently used in our nation’s mass shootings to be restricted. We wanted increased resources for the chronically underfunded mental health supports that our students need to be socially and emotionally healthy.
This week your commission released its final report.
Among other things, your recommendation is that school systems consider training and arming personnel, including teachers, as “an effective tool in stopping acts of school violence.” You considered raising the age limit for gun purchases but determined it “unlikely to be an effective method for preventing or reducing school shootings.”
The report did not discuss additional federal funding for mental health.
When our students are having trouble mastering a concept, we find an alternative way to teach it. Since clear public polling didn’t seem to impact your commission’s decision-making process, let me explain my thoughts on the issue another way.
Like so many others, I have dedicated my life to public education and believe deeply in its potential for changing futures. Our schools must be safe and nurturing spaces for those paths to develop, and occasionally they are not. I often play through the mental scenario of an armed intruder bursting through the classroom door, and I have no doubt that, if it came to that, my colleagues and I would lay down our lives for these students that we care so much about.
But I would quit teaching before I’d carry a gun in school — or even work in a place where my colleagues were armed.
What makes the magic in our public schools possible is the positive culture that professional educators work so hard to establish. The relationships we build with our students help them see our classrooms as a safe harbor, a place where they will be respected and given the support they need to succeed. That’s why, during a lockdown, I can look at each individual in my care and see the trust written on every single face — despite the fact that I’m unarmed.
We can’t keep that all-important culture intact while militarizing our classrooms. It’s as simple as that.
It’s critical for you to listen to educators and to parents who, unlike you, have chosen to entrust their children to public schools. Hear us when we say that adding more guns to our buildings is not going to solve school shootings. It will only make things worse. Statistically speaking, our schools are still very safe places to be. The notion of a pistol-packing teacher taking out a villain in a blaze of gunfire sounds like the action movie fantasy of an out-of-touch, NRA-backed politician.
Let’s leave the firearms to law enforcement professionals.
7th grade public school teacher