The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Woodstock can’t be duplicated. Perhaps we should leave it at that.

A photo from Daniel Bukszpan’s new book, “Woodstock: 50 Years of Peace and Music.” (Joshua White)

“Woodstock 50” never had the allure of the original Woodstock tag “3 Days of Peace and Music,” and after a mad scramble to reprise the 1969 festival, it was finally canceled Wednesday. Thwarted by permit denials and financial troubles, the 50th anniversary event, scheduled to start Aug. 16, had once promised a blockbuster lineup, including Miley Cyrus, Halsey and Canned Heat, but in the end the whole enterprise came crashing down.

If all this futile scrambling makes you tired, a book like Daniel Bukszpan’s “Woodstock: 50 Years of Peace and Music” is a calming, nostalgic read for those who want a quick and easy take on the iconic event. But the truth is, Woodstock can never be duplicated, no matter how much producers and music fans try.

If you were around in the summer of 1969 — as I was — chances are you heard a high-pitched voice singing, “I’m goin’ up the country, baby, don’t you wanna go.” In August 1969, friends invited me and my then-boyfriend to go with them to Woodstock. Millions had heard Canned Heat’s invitation; 400,000 replied in the affirmative. But I had to work. Boyfriend, recently back from Vietnam and adept at hitchhiking, probably would have gone, but I think he had to work, too, delivering food for some chicken joint. Or perhaps another AWOL soldier was scheduled for delivery at his pad, a safe house equipped with working venetian blinds and large windows from which to watch for lurking government vehicles. Such were the days.

I saw the Beatles live, but no, I didn’t scream. It’s time to take female fans seriously.

In the festival’s opening set, Richie Havens sang his song “Freedom,” an apt beginning for an event all about freedom. Bukszpan’s book embellishes that ideal. Other anniversary books — Dale Bell’s “Woodstock: An Inside Look at the Movie That Shook Up the World and Defined a Generation” and John Kane’s “Pilgrims of Woodstock: Never-Before-Seen Photos” — do much the same.

This vision of the event — a celebration of hippie ethos and style — however photogenic, presents a selective view of the ’60s. Though Woodstock was the apex of hippie culture, most young people in America could not or did not want to attend. Many carried on as usual, dressed boringly, went to boring jobs and worried about the future in standard ways. This in no way obliterates the historical significance of Woodstock, but it does complicate how its story is told, and what it has come to represent.

It is impossible today to imagine 400,000 people lounging peacefully in the mud and sharing stuff. Has anyone wondered how many, if any, guns there might have been at Woodstock? Any large gathering today provokes this question, but, given Bukszpan’s emphasis on peace and music (there is a chapter for each act, even the ones you have never heard of), it seems obscene to ask it of Woodstock. Bukszpan keeps at a distance events such as the Manson Family murders, the stabbing death during the Rolling Stones’ set at a concert in Altamont, Calif., and the linked escalations of the Vietnam War and the protests against it, making his a nice coffee-table book. He wants to focus on “what went right” at Woodstock, but the larger history of 1969 should not be avoided, because so much went wrong. There is no nudity in the book, either. (“Pilgrims of Woodstock,” a collection of photos and interviews of attendees, makes up for it.)

The accounts of cooperation and generosity Bukszpan does include make good reading. Building the stage, along with the sound and lighting setups, required speedy, can-do American ingenuity. Wavy Gravy, a.k.a. Hugh Romney, worked tirelessly to feed, clean and heal anyone in need. The event’s promoters transported Wavy and his comrades from their commune in New Mexico to Woodstock via private jet, just one zingy detail that highlights the codependence between the counterculture and business, which continues today.

Nirvana manager Danny Goldberg waited 25 years to write his Kurt Cobain book. Here’s the Kurt he knew.

Perhaps the mess and cancellation of Woodstock 50 were inevitable. Before “Mad Men’s” Don Draper intuited the catchy phrase about buying the world a Coke, peace and love were being commercialized. The backers of Woodstock figured this would happen. Despite taking huge losses during the event, they made a fortune once the 1970 film of the festival was released. Films, soundtrack albums, books and the anniversary concerts — each increasingly violent and expensive to attend — this is the commercial legacy of Woodstock 1969. You can still buy a piece of history and groove on it. Rhino records is offering a 38-disc box set of the original performances, along with a Blu-ray of Michael Wadleigh’s film “Woodstock” for $799. (Fun fact: That would have been about $114 in 1969.)

Amid all this fluster of trying to relive the past, or regain our original, dare I say “better,” selves — both impossible endeavors — you might wonder what happened to my antiwar, peace-marching subversive boyfriend. He married me, I divorced him, and some time during the 1980s, he re-upped with the Army and became a lifer, served in the Gulf War, and retired with a military pension. You cannot beat history, so do not even try.

This review has been revised to reflect the cancellation of the Woodstock 50 Washington celebration in suburban Maryland.

Sibbie O’Sullivan is a former teacher in the Honors College at the University of Maryland. Her book of essays about John Lennon is forthcoming from Mad Creek Books.

A note to our readers

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.