Of course, the temptation is to just leave out the protein entirely. That felt a bit defeatist, and then really all I’d have was a grilled cheese with a bunch of condiments (not that there’s anything wrong with that). I wanted something more substantial, that would replicate the stateliness and height of the original. I’ve had a few restaurant versions made with tempeh and liked them, but the fermented soybean product didn’t quite fit the profile for me for this recipe, so I turned to that classic, “meaty” vegetarian staple, the portobello mushroom.
Initial tests were promising, if not perfect. Roasting thinly sliced portobello caps at a high heat cooked off so much moisture I practically had mushroom jerky. Tasty, but the sandwich felt more like a mushroom melt. Next, I tried whole caps. They didn’t cook down enough, leaving me with mushrooms that were too thick, squeaky and stringy for my taste. For help, I turned to Washington chef Rob Rubba, whose restaurant Oyster Oyster places an emphasis on locally foraged mushrooms. I was already ambivalent about having to use both the oven and stovetop to make the sandwich, and he suggested I consider pressing mushrooms in the skillet. My next test involved slicing the portobello caps in half through the equator, arranging them in layers in a nonstick pan and weighing them down with a cast-iron skillet. Bingo. The mushrooms gave up most, but not all, of their liquid, leaving me with stackable slices with just enough bite and juiciness to almost replicate a pile of deli cuts.
Rubba also mentioned that sometimes he rubs the mushrooms with a miso-mustard mix to get a crust that in this case would offer some of the same textural contrast as corned beef. Again, he was spot on. I assembled a spice and Dijon mustard paste that incorporated a few of the ingredients you might find in the pickling brine for the beef — allspice, mustard, red pepper flakes, salt, black pepper and coriander. Spread onto the mushroom slices and briefly browned in the skillet, it added the right amount of punch and crunch.
The rest was straightforward. Sliced Swiss, check. Rye bread, check (you can use seeded, seedless or marble). Russian dressing, check. I’m offering a modified version of the dressing from our archives, but feel free to use store-bought. All that was left was to griddle the sandwich — a “mushreuben,” as my colleague Kari Sonde and others have called it — to golden brown perfection and dig in. Even without the meat, it will meet with your approval.
Recipe notes: The sum total of these ingredients makes for a high-sodium meal, though steps such as using less dressing, finding a low-sodium or homemade bread and reducing the salt in the spice rub can help bring the numbers down, if desired.
Leftover dressing can be stored in an airtight container for up to 3 days. Extra mushrooms can also be refrigerated for a few days for additional sandwiches, though you may want to warm them slightly or allow to come to room temperature before using.
For the dressing
- 1/4 cup mayonnaise
- 1/4 cup ketchup
- 1 1/2 teaspoons prepared (white) horseradish or peeled, freshly grated horseradish root, patted dry
- 1/2 teaspoon hot paprika (may substitute sweet paprika and a pinch of cayenne pepper)
- 1 tablespoon finely chopped pickles (may substitute pickle relish)
- 1 clove garlic, minced
For the mushrooms
- 2 tablespoons Dijon mustard
- 2 teaspoons ground coriander
- 1 teaspoon brown mustard seeds
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1/4 teaspoon red pepper flakes
- Pinch ground allspice
- Freshly ground black pepper
- Vegetable oil
- 1 pound portobello mushrooms, sliced in half horizontally
For the sandwich
- 4 slices rye bread (seeded, seedless or marble)
- 4 slices Swiss cheese
- 2/3 cup sauerkraut, drained
- 1 tablespoon unsalted butter (may substitute salted butter)
Make the dressing: In a medium bowl, using an immersion blender, process the mayonnaise, ketchup, horseradish, paprika, pickles and garlic, pulsing until well combined. (You can also use a food processor, but consider doubling the batch for easier processing.) The yield is about 1/2 cup; you’ll have extra for more sandwiches or other uses. Transfer to an airtight container and refrigerate until needed.
Make the mushrooms: In a small bowl, stir together the mustard, coriander, mustard seeds, salt, red pepper flakes, allspice and a few grinds of black pepper until thoroughly combined.
Coat the bottom of a 12-inch nonstick skillet with a thin layer of oil and set over medium heat for several minutes, or until you feel a decent blast of heat when holding your hand an inch or so above the skillet. Arrange the mushrooms in the skillet in two layers. Wrap the bottom of a cast-iron skillet or a plate (weighted with heavy cans) in foil and place on top of the mushrooms; the goal is to press the liquid out of the mushrooms. Cook, undisturbed, for 6 minutes.
Remove the skillet or plate, flip the mushrooms over, arranging them so the thickest slices are toward the middle, or the hottest part of the pan. Return the skillet or plate on top of the mushrooms and cook until the mushrooms have significantly reduced in size and almost all the liquid has evaporated, another 5 to 6 minutes. If there’s still liquid in the skillet, uncover the mushrooms, briefly increase the heat to medium-high and cook until the water is mostly gone.
Transfer the mushrooms to a platter and spread an even, thin layer of the mustard mixture on one side of each mushroom slice. (On the slices from the top halves of the mushrooms, the mixture adheres best to the exterior rather than the flesh.)
Wipe out the skillet, add another thin coating of oil and return to medium heat (no need to preheat more than 1 minute or so, as it will still be quite hot). Place the mushrooms in a single layer, coated side down, and cook until browned and crisp in spots, 2 to 3 minutes, working in batches. A little of the coating may come off; that’s okay — just pile it on when assembling the sandwiches. Wipe the skillet clean.
Make the sandwiches: Spread about 1 tablespoon of the dressing on each of the 4 slices of bread. On 2 of them, build the sandwiches, evenly dividing the cheese, mushrooms and sauerkraut, followed by the other 2 slices of bread.
In the skillet over medium heat, melt the butter until bubbling slightly. Griddle the sandwiches on both sides (do one at a time if you’re tight on space) until golden brown and crisp, 2 to 3 minutes per side. Cut in half and serve.
Calories: 548; Total Fat: 25 g; Saturated Fat: 14 g; Cholesterol: 67 mg; Sodium: 1899 mg; Carbohydrates: 57 g; Dietary Fiber: 7 g; Sugar: 18 g; Protein: 26 g.
From Voraciously staff writer Becky Krystal; dressing recipe adapted from cookbook author John Holl.
Tested by Becky Krystal; email questions to email@example.com.
Did you make this recipe? Take a photo and tag us on Instagram with #eatvoraciously.