The Washington Post

Taste Test: Ice cream sandwiches

Ice cream sandwich taste test winner from Cork Market: Peanut Butter cookie and Banana and Caramel ice cream sandwich. (Deb Lindsey/FOR THE WASHINGTON POST)

We’re about a month shy of National Ice Cream Sandwich Day but right up against the belly of our nation’s birthday — not to mention it’s high season for locally made frozen treats. So we figured a taste test was in order.

We rounded up 17 samples from bakeries, grocery stores, specialty shops and a food truck. This was a blind tasting; judges rated cookies and ice cream separately (on a scale of 1 to 5) and gave an overall score.

The winner — from the executive chef for Cork Wine Bar and Restaurant and its nearby Cork Market — made us swoon. Kristin Hutter swirls a luscious house-made caramel sauce into a subtle, creamy house-made banana ice cream that’s sandwiched between outstanding house-made peanut butter cookies.

“I get to taste flavors she comes up with, so I have the best job,” says co-owner Diane Gross. Cork’s ice cream sandwiches are a summer-only dessert, and the winning ’wich has been offered since the summer of 2011.

Bonnie S. Benwick

If you’re an ice cream novice, if you’re in need of a refresher course or if you like to freestyle in the recipe department, this might be the help you’ve been waiting for: base recipes, current standards for various frozen desserts and tips for serving and storing.

Here are the contestants, in order of ranking, with some of the judges’ comments.

Top 5

Banana Caramel Ice Cream/Peanut Butter Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches

Cork Market and Tasting Room, 1805 14th St. NW, 202-265-2674

$4 each

A chorus of flavors; delicious homemade taste; the cookie is actually crunchy. OMG!

Ginger Snapwich With Lemon Ice Cream

Bakeshop, 1025 N. Fillmore St., Arlington, 571-970-6460

$5 each

Stellar cookie — like a chewy molasses — and very good ice cream, but a not super-interesting flavor.

Ginger Rosemary Ice Cream Sandwich by CreamCycle

Available at Bean & Bite, 1152 15th St. NW, 202-296-3078; Smucker Farms, 2118 14th St. NW, 202-986-7332

$5 each

Lovely, subtle flavor in the ice cream. Wish the cookie had been baked a bit more.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich with Vanilla Ice Cream

Captain Cookie & the Milkman food truck, various locations in the District (weekdays), 202-556-3396

$4 each

Cookie consistency was great; ice cream was creamy but too melty.

Saffron and Rosewater Ice Cream Sandwich

Meat in a Box, 312 S. Washington St., Falls Church, 703-533-9070

$3.99 each

Crisp, cracker-type cookie made it tough to eat as a sandwich. The ice cream’s flavoring was interesting, but a bit heavy on the rosewater.

Good to middling

Flying Saucer (chocolate cookie with vanilla ice cream)

Carvel, various locations

$1.99 each

Creamy ice cream; the cookie stayed crunchy.

Ciao Bella Key Lime Graham Gelato Squares

Whole Foods Markets, various locations

About $1.30 each

Great tang to the ice cream, but the cookie is blah.

Klondike Mrs. Fields Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches

Widely available

About $1 each (sold in a four-pack)

Ice cream reminiscent of soft-serve or marshmallow cream. Cookie has stale-freezer taste.

Skinny Cow Chocolate Peanut Butter Low Fat Ice Cream Sandwiches

Widely available

About 75 cents each (sold in a six-pack)

Decent hit of peanut butter. The cookie was too soft.

Trader Joe’s Sublime Ice Cream Sandwiches

Trader Joe’s, various locations

About $1 each (sold in a four-pack)

Way too sweet and artificial-tasting; lots of chips.

Lucerne Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches

Safeway, various locations

30 cents each (sold in a 12-pack)

Breath-minty ice cream, gummy cookie.

600-Lb. Gorillas Premium Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich, Vanilla Bean (tie)

BJ’s Wholesale Club, various locations

83 cents each (sold in a 12-pack)

Reminds me of summer at the pool; good hit of toffee.

Imagine Almond Dream Lil’ Dreamers Vanilla Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert Sandwiches (tie)

Widely available

About 50 cents each (sold in an eight-pack)

Tasted freezerish; no richness or depth of flavor in the sandwich or ice cream.

So Delicious Dairy Free Vanilla Minis

Widely available

About 57 cents each (sold in an eight-pack)

Cookie was gooey, the ice cream too thin.

Not impressive

Tofutti Cuties Vanilla Sandwiches (tie)

Widely available

About 44 cents each (sold in an eight-pack)

It’s like Cool Whip on a cookie.

Whole Treat Organic Ice Cream Sandwiches (tie)

Whole Foods Markets, various locations

83 cents each (sold in an eight-pack)

Flabby cookie, bland ice cream.

Julie’s Organic Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

Widely available at health food stores

About $1 each (sold in a six-pack)

Sticks to your teeth; bad, sad.

Bonnie S. Benwick has the job most envied among cocktail-party conversations. If they only knew ... Cook with her each week at Dinner in Minutes:



Success! Check your inbox for details. You might also like:

Please enter a valid email address

See all newsletters

Show Comments
Most Read



Success! Check your inbox for details.

See all newsletters

Your Three. Video curated for you.

To keep reading, please enter your email address.

You’ll also receive from The Washington Post:
  • A free 6-week digital subscription
  • Our daily newsletter in your inbox

Please enter a valid email address

I have read and agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Please indicate agreement.

Thank you.

Check your inbox. We’ve sent an email explaining how to set up an account and activate your free digital subscription.