In our ongoing quest to offload some work (kidding!), we sweet-talked NBC4 news anchor Wendy Rieger into picking a date for Taylor. Rieger sorted through a few candidates, dismissing one because: “She’s looking for a tall, handsome, 30-year-old Master of the Universe. I fear she would be eyeing the exits before the appetizers arrived.” Rieger ultimately decided on Katie, whose interests, she told us, intersect with Taylor’s enough to make it a promising match on paper. “More importantly, they both write with similar voices.” But would a love of sports and a comparable way with words be enough? We sent them to Firefly in Dupont Circle to find out.
Katie: I’d say he’s pretty on par with the type of guy that I would date. So I was pleasantly surprised.
Taylor: I thought she was very pretty. That was definitely the first thought that ran into my head. Definitely my type.
Katie: We shook hands. We started talking about things we’d done this weekend and started getting into what we do and what schools we went to.
Taylor: There was that first-date awkwardness that we definitely waded through — but it wasn’t uncomfortable. She’s an LSU fan, and I’m a big football fan, so that was a good common starting point.
Katie: I have a lot of nonprofit work that I’ve done before, and he works for a nonprofit, so that was similar. I feel like we did have a decent amount of things in common.
Taylor: She’s about a year or two older than me, but she graduated college probably three years ahead of me. So we’re just off by a little bit, nothing crazy but probably a half-step off in stages of life, I guess. She’s probably not the kind of person I’d pick out at a bar, but she was definitely cool, and I definitely warmed up to her as the evening went on.
Katie: He seemed more nervous than I. I don’t know if that’s his personality; maybe he’s a little more reserved or quiet. I’d say I had a little more command of the conversation.
Taylor: I’d say that’s a fair comment. It was probably a little first-date jitters and the whole experience of going into it not knowing what to expect.
Katie: It was friendly but nothing overly flirtatious. I usually like someone that’s a little more assertive and outgoing, but I did feel like we had a lot of things in common. I was probably cracking more jokes than he was, but I’d say we got along in that sense.
Taylor: I made her laugh a couple of times, so I think that was a good sign. We decided to nix the dessert, so we went to Buffalo Billiards to watch the end of the Capitals game. It was probably 9 or a little after. She [suggested] Buffalo Billiards. If she hadn’t said it, I would have.
Katie: We watched some of the end of the game, and we had a beer or two. Then we left there maybe at 10:15. We ended up hugging goodbye, and then he ended up asking for my number, which I was a little taken aback [by] — just with the assertive factor. That’s when he said he would be in touch with me. I think I would consider [going out again], but then again, I don’t know.
Taylor: I’ll probably give her a call sometime next week. It was a good time; she was cool.
RATE THE DATE
Katie: I’d [rate the date] a strong 3 [out of 5]. Overall I think it went well for what it was.
Taylor: Can I go with a 31 / 2? Definitely bordering on the romantically interested but still kind of unsure.
UPDATE: Taylor says he has been really busy and is seeing a few other people, so
“it just didn’t work out.” Katie confirmed she hasn’t heard from Taylor. “I’m not completely surprised. I think we could both kind of tell it was a nice time, but I think there was definitely something missing.”
Wendy Rieger says: “This date ranks up there with the Golf Channel when it comes to fireworks. [But] give it time. I predict these two will meet again in the future after they’ve dated awhile in D.C. and will leap into each other’s arms. Trust me.”
For stories, features such as Gene Weingarten, @Work Advice and more, visit WP Magazine.
Follow the Magazine on Twitter.
Like us on Facebook.
E-mail us at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Tell us what past Washington Post story or person in the news you want us to update. E-mail