DEAR AMY: I’m a 26-year-old single father with a daughter who is 5. My ex and I split when our daughter was an infant.
I had a girlfriend “Debbie” for three years. We lived together and shared custody of the child. She was a crucial part of my daughter’s life from the ages of 1 to 4.
Debbie and I have been apart for 16 months but have stayed in touch. My daughter will talk about Debbie as if they just hung out the other week. After 16 months of zero contact, she still asks when she is going to see Debbie. When I told Debbie, she brought up the idea of public visits with me and my daughter with the hopes of the two of them becoming buddies down the road.
The child’s mother thinks our daughter will one day forget Debbie, and seeing her would tease the child about the possibility of Debbie and me getting back together. I don’t want to toy with my child’s emotions; Debbie and I know we’re done for good. -- J
DEAR J: You cannot make someone “disappear” from your daughter’s mind and heart simply by removing contact. Every adult in her life is vital to this child’s development and she is proving this by keeping “Debbie” present, even if the two never see each other.
Because Debbie seems to have been a loving and involved co-parent and a benign force in your daughter’s life, you should promote them spending time together (along with you) occasionally.
Your ex is mistaken: Your daughter will not forget Debbie, even if her memories of their time together change or fade. Seeing Debbie will replace the buildup in your daughter’s imagination with real-world experiences and a more balanced attachment.
Seeing you and Debbie peacefully go from being partners to friends will demonstrate to her that people don’t just disappear from a person’s life when they move out and move on. What a wonderful lesson for her.
DEAR AMY: After several dating experiences in college, I happened upon a great guy while studying abroad. After returning to the United States, nearly daily contact galvanized me over the subsequent years to find opportunities to visit him.
Love blossomed, but these discontinuous periods of proximity made our relationship ephemeral. He was never comfortable with my proposal to call him my “boyfriend,” yet there was always a clear implication of mutual monogamy.
Recently during a drunken lapse of judgment I kissed a complete stranger. I felt I owed my boyfriend a confession. Unfortunately, he was planning a trip here to visit.
I apologized for my mistake, but he has not communicated with me since. He has admitted to more than a stray kiss before, so I can appreciate how he must be feeling — but this is not the first time he has cut off communication with me.
I worry about his nonconfrontational approach. Nearly five years in, I no longer know how to proceed. His silence is debilitating, but I still believe giving up on each other would be a lifelong mistake. -- Hopelessly Impaled
DEAR IMPALED: This man is not your boyfriend (according to him). He does not require (or deserve) a confession about a stray kiss.
His silence is not impaling you. It is setting you free, because this relationship does not have a future.
Five years is a long time to invest in a relationship that is so one-sided. Unless he initiates a conversation or shows up on your doorstep, it’s over. Even if he does, it’s most likely still over.
DEAR AMY: Thanks for backing up “Exhausted Gran,” who did not want to baby-sit her grandchildren. Grandparents do not always make the best baby sitters. Many don’t have the energy to keep up with small children, some are too indulgent or unwilling to follow the child’s routines or the house rules, and some frankly just don’t enjoy small children.
There is nothing about being a blood relation that makes a grandparent a better caregiver than a loving, energetic, conscientious baby sitter like the wonderful ones who have cared for our daughter. -- Mother of a Preschooler
DEAR MOTHER: I agree. Thank you.