Copper is everywhere — in the Earth’s crust, in electrical wiring, in our bodies and, during the coronavirus pandemic, it’s even been showing up in masks.
Humans have been making discoveries about and finding new applications for the reddish brown metal — which also appears in the form of a mineral and an element — since before recorded history. Ancient people used it to make jewelry and tools; modern researchers are investigating its antimicrobial properties and the roles it plays as an essential nutrient.
But as scientific evidence continues to emerge, so, too, do claims about copper’s therapeutic properties. While some companies are promoting copper masks as a shield against viruses and bacteria, others are plugging supplements containing copper to boost the immune system and advertising copper accessories and clothing to reduce pain.
Here’s what experts and science say copper can and cannot do when it comes to virus protection, immune system support and pain relief.
Knowledge of copper’s infection-killing abilities stretches back thousands of years. Its earliest use in medicine is believed to be recorded in the Smith Papyrus, an ancient Egyptian medical text.
People had observed that if they stored water in copper vessels, “members of their family had lesser chances of developing acute diarrheal diseases from bad water, and mortality, especially among infants and children, went way down,” Schmidt said. “Fast-forward to now, we understand how copper is inactivating microorganisms and it’s a pretty remarkable and straightforward mechanism.”
When bacteria come into contact with the metal and its alloys such as brass, the copper attracts electrons from the microbes, producing free radicals, or highly reactive, unstable molecules, that kill pathogens “very quickly and without mercy,” Schmidt said. Copper has an equally devastating effect on viruses, he noted, generating oxygen molecules that behave like “an exploding grenade.”
“The oxygen shrapnel first destroys the envelope” of the viruses, Schmidt said. “Then, additional oxygen radicals come in to destroy the viral RNA, and if the instruction set is not intact, you have no virus.”
Studies have found that copper surfaces can limit the spread of bacteria such as E. coli and salmonella, as well as highly infectious viruses like norovirus. And research conducted during the pandemic has shown that it has the same effect on the coronavirus.
Those powerful antimicrobial properties have sparked the production of and consumer interest in masks containing the metal, which purport to offer protection against infectious particles. Although many of these claims may have some theoretical merit, experts are urging people to exercise caution until more data on efficacy can be gathered.
“They’re all the product of people’s ingenuity, but we don’t know whether they’re useful,” said William Schaffner, medical director of the National Foundation for Infectious Diseases.
Research has shown that copper-infused masks can quickly inactivate viruses that come into contact with the material. A 2010 study found that N95 respirators impregnated with copper effectively destroyed the flu virus on the surface of the mask without compromising filtration ability. The peer-reviewed study was conducted by researchers affiliated with Cupron Scientific, which is now selling reusable masks with copper.
Several of the scientists involved in developing Cupron’s antiviral mask technology have since released another paper, reporting that N95s and regular surgical masks with copper-oxide microparticles in their outside layers inactivated the novel coronavirus by more than 99.9 percent within one minute of contact. Those findings have not undergone peer review.
While the existing research is sound, “you and I are not interested in protecting masks from flu. We’re interested in protecting people,” Schaffner said.
Logically, he said, if the virus is inactivated on the surface of the mask, you are less likely to breathe it in and less likely to contaminate your hands if you touch your mask. “I love the logic,” he said. But, the question remains: “Does it really work in preventing illness, infection in people?”
There are several unknowns about copper masks that may affect their efficacy. Cloth and surgical masks don’t always fit snugly, creating gaps where air can flow around the covering instead of being filtered through it, said Linsey Marr, a Virginia Tech professor who studies airborne transmission of infectious diseases. Adding copper may also make a mask stiffer, causing it to conform less well to your face, or compromise the tightness of the material’s weave, Marr said.
“For the copper to work, the mask has to physically trap the virus in the first place,” she said. “The copper is not like a magnet for the virus.”
Experts say more studies are needed. “There are various layers of evidence,” said Monica Gandhi, a professor of medicine and an infectious-disease expert at the University of California at San Francisco. “We’re still sitting at the theoretical, totally makes sense layer of evidence.”
One possible next step would be conducting laboratory tests where the masks are placed on mannequins and infectious particles, in droplet and aerosol size, are sprayed at the coverings to see how many make it through, Gandhi said.
Still, if you find an affordable, tightly woven and well-fitted mask that has copper, experts say there probably isn’t any harm in using it. Just keep in mind that research has not yet shown whether the masks offer any more protection than multiple-layer cloth coverings or medical-grade masks recommended by public health officials.
“At this point in time, you use it with the same level of caution you would use all masks,” Schmidt said.
Immune system support
One of copper’s many essential functions in the human body is to help maintain a healthy immune system. But experts strongly advise against taking copper supplements to prevent infections or illnesses.
“That’s the dangerous route,” said Svetlana Lutsenko, a professor of physiology at the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine who studies copper. “Copper has to be really balanced, just like anything we do or eat.”
The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine has taken a similar stance, publishing a fact-checking article on its website refuting the claim that copper supplements can help the body fight off covid-19.
“There is no evidence that copper kills germs inside your body,” the article states. “There is no evidence that copper or other dietary supplements can ‘boost’ or ‘supercharge’ your immune system to protect you from infections.”
Consuming too much copper also may cause toxicity, said Mikhail Kogan, medical director of George Washington University’s Center for Integrative Medicine. For most adults, the recommended dietary intake of copper is 900 micrograms per day — an amount that can be reached from a healthful diet alone, according to the National Academies. Copper-rich foods include leafy greens such as spinach, as well as certain nuts and dark chocolate.
Chronic exposure to high amounts of copper may cause liver damage and gastrointestinal problems such as abdominal pain, cramps, nausea, diarrhea and vomiting, according to the Office of Dietary Supplements at the National Institutes of Health.
Lutsenko and Kogan both emphasized that copper supplements should not be taken unless directed by a physician. “Do not use anything oral or do not even attempt to try to inhale anything copper-containing,” Kogan said. “You’ll get in a lot of trouble.”
While copper has been used in wound care, claims that products containing the metal can relieve pain are not supported by science, experts said.
“Copper for pain, especially those copper bracelets, that’s been debunked,” Kogan said.
A 2013 peer-reviewed study examining whether copper bracelets offered any relief to people with rheumatoid arthritis found that the accessory “did not appear to have any meaningful therapeutic effect, beyond that of a placebo, for alleviating symptoms and combating disease activity,” the researchers wrote.
Since then, at least one athletic apparel company producing copper-infused garments has been charged by the Federal Trade Commission for deceptive advertising. In 2015, the company agreed to pay $1.35 million to settle the charges.
“If you see an ad for a product that promises to replace the need for drugs or surgery, talk to a healthcare professional before you spend your money,” Jessica Rich, then the director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, said in a news release at the time.
Your Life at Home
The Post’s best advice for living during the pandemic.
Health & Wellness: What to know before your vaccine appointment | Creative coping tips | What to do about Zoom fatigue
Newsletter: Sign up for Eat Voraciously — one quick, adaptable and creative recipe in your inbox every Monday through Thursday.
Parenting: Guidance for vaccinated parents and unvaccinated kids | Preparing kids for “the return” | Pandemic decision fatigue
Food: Dinner in Minutes | Use the library as a valuable (and free) resource for cookbooks, kitchen tools and more
Arts & Entertainment: Ten TV shows with jaw-dropping twists | Give this folk rock duo 27 minutes. They’ll give you a musically heartbreaking world.
Home & Garden: Setting up a home workout space | How to help plants thrive in spring | Solutions for stains and scratches
Travel: Vaccines and summer travel — what families need to know | Take an overnight trip with your two-wheeled vehicle