In the end, there was no security threat — just two brothers with a poorly conceived plan and 21 jugs of gasoline. On Friday, Canadian officials agreed to drop terrorism hoax charges against the Roys and release them from jail, and explained for the first time what had led to their arrest. The men, it turned out, had been trying to see if they could make it to Mexico in a car with no license plates, and without stopping for gas or presenting any identification along the way.
“This was more stupid than it was criminal,” Crown prosecutor Brian Munn told the judge, according to the Canadian Broadcasting Corp.
The CBC reported that the two brothers remained silent in court as an agreed-upon set of facts was read out loud, detailing how their escapades had landed them in jail. It all started on the day before their arrest, when they purchased the vintage Skylark. The sedan didn’t come with a certificate of registration or any other legal documents, and didn’t have any plates, but that didn’t stop the Roys from setting out to drive the length of the United States.
For reasons unknown, the brothers decided that they didn’t want to stop at any gas stations until they crossed into Mexico, so they loaded up the back seat and the trunk of the two-door coupe with 21 jugs of gasoline. Naturally, the antique car wasn’t equipped with a GPS, so they planned out their travels on paper maps and threw those into the back as well, along with some food for the 5,000-mile journey.
The larger issue, however was that they didn’t have passports or any other forms of ID with them. To avoid having to deal with border agents, the Roys decided that they would take a back road through a remote stretch of the North Country where they were unlikely to encounter checkpoints, and then sneak into Maine.
Their old-school navigation methods evidently failed: At around 10 a.m. on Oct. 26, they found themselves approaching one of the largest checkpoints in New Brunswick. They were less than 350 miles from their home in Halifax, Nova Scotia, and already, the journey wasn’t going as planned.
Bailey had been driving, and Damien sat in the passenger seat. According to the CBC, Munn said they both “froze” when they realized what was happening. The Skylark abruptly came to a stop in the middle of the road.
“It was very strange,” Kevin Peck, who lives on the Canadian side of the border and happened to come across the car, later told CTV News. “There was room to pass on the left-hand side, and as I was passing by I kind of glanced over and there were two gentlemen in the car that were not moving, looking straight ahead, and the windows were all fogged up.”
Officials on both sides of the border were unnerved. Two officers from the Canada Border Services Agency went over to investigate. One tried to talk to the brothers and ask if they were okay, but got no response: The men just kept staring dead ahead, gazing out over the pine trees and the deep drifts of snow.
Then, the border agents noticed that the back seat of the Skylark was littered with jugs of gas. They quickly backed away, closed down the checkpoint and summoned the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. A chaotic scene ensued.
"There were probably 100 plus security personnel — Canadian and U.S. — surrounding the vehicle,” John Slipp, who owns a duty-free store near the checkpoint, told CTV News. “There was a helicopter and a SWAT team.” Eventually, he was told to evacuate.
Over the next six hours, police dogs sniffed the brothers’ car, a drone circled overhead and police tried in vain to talk to them. They still didn’t move. Meanwhile, traffic came to a standstill, and disgruntled drivers complained that being redirected to the nearest border crossing, 100 miles to the south, was going to make their trips take hours longer than they had planned.
The silent standoff finally came to an end at around 4:30 p.m., when the Mounties brought in a military-style armored truck. As the intimidating-looking vehicle closed in, Bailey Roy hit the gas. He sped across the border into Maine and came to a stop as the truck rammed into a parked U.S. Customs and Border Protection vehicle, creating a blockade. The two brothers spilled out of the passenger-side door, and were immediately taken into custody. Nearly six hours later, the checkpoint finally reopened.
Later, the Telegraph-Journal reported, the Roys told police that they had realized there was no way they would be able to illegally cross into the United States. Instead, they had decided to stop at the border “just to see how things would play out.”
They ended up spending the next four months behind bars. Within 24 hours of his arrest, U.S. officials handed Bailey over to Canadian authorities so that he could be prosecuted. Damien, who had tried to claim asylum, spent roughly a month in detention before he, too, was sent back to face trial in the Provincial Court of New Brunswick. Both were charged with committing a hoax related to terrorist activity, and willfully obstructing peace officers.
Although neither had a criminal record, it also wasn’t their first brush with the law. In 2015, the brothers, then teenagers, were reported missing after they went on a camping trip and failed to return. Their disappearance prompted a massive search-and-rescue operation, but after nearly six weeks, they returned home on their own, completely unscathed. A judge later placed them in an adult diversion program that allowed them to avoid being prosecuted on obstruction charges.
At the time, their father, Corey Roy, told the Chronicle Herald that the boys had developed an interest in survivalism, and often made extended trips into the woods to practice living in isolation. He said they had no interest in drugs, alcohol and other typical teenage mischief, and adhered to strict diets where they ate little other than raw vegetables and protein. They had sold off most of their possessions, but held onto their car, which they had been using to make “sudden, secret runs” to Montreal, Toronto and Quebec City.
Speaking to CTV News in October after his sons were arrested at the border, Roy said that he was just grateful that they hadn’t been shot. Damien and Bailey had been getting into trouble since elementary school, when they had to be separated because their teacher couldn’t handle both of them at once, he said. Both were smart when they wanted to be, he insisted, and read constantly, preferring each other’s company to being around anyone else. He couldn’t explain what had motivated their bizarre behavior, and added that he wished that he had spent more time monitoring what they were looking at on the Internet.
“They have no respect for law enforcement whatsoever,” he said. “They go for the reaction.”
On Friday, both of the Roy brothers declined to discuss their exploits with reporters. During the hearing, Damien raised only one question: What had happened to the Skylark? It was still in Maine, Munn told him, outside of the Crown’s jurisdiction.
According to the Telegraph-Journal, the prosecutor argued that their stunt had a serious economic impact on both Canada and the United States, since hundreds of commercial trucks typically pass through the Houlton-Woodstock checkpoint, which is located at the northern terminus of Interstate 95, each day. But he also acknowledged that the brothers had maintained that their misadventures hadn’t been politically motivated, and that they had no plan to commit an act of terrorism.
“To use the words of Bailey Roy himself during an interview, essentially what they had done was ‘stupid,’” he said.
After the terrorism hoax charges were dropped, both brothers pleaded guilty to obstructing law enforcement, and were sentenced to three months in prison with credit for time served, allowing them to walk free that same day. Judge David Walker wished them good luck, the CBC reported.
They left the courthouse dressed in the same gym shorts and sneakers that they had been wearing when they set off on their road trip and began looking for a ride back to their mother’s house.