The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

‘I should’ve just kept her and gone to jail’: Custody battle ends in 3-year-old chained in a burning car

Martin Pereira's ex-fiancee says the custody battle for the couple's 3-year-old daughter Zoey led to a violent crime in New York. (Video: CBS New York (WCBS-TV))
Placeholder while article actions load

Cherone Coleman was worried. In March, she had split from her fiance, Martin Pereira. Now, the couple was waging war in a Queens courtroom over the custody of their 3-year-old daughter, Zoey.

But as Coleman, a 36-year-old medical assistant, told the New York Daily News on Monday, Pereira had become increasingly unhinged in recent weeks as the parental squabbles continued. Despite the mother’s reservations, a judge ordered Pereira to take Zoey to his home on Long Island last weekend — a decision that would prove devastating.

“I should’ve just kept her and gone to jail,” Coleman told the Daily News.

On Sunday night, a 2008 Audi A6 exploded into flames near Baisley Pond Park in the Springfield Gardens neighborhood of Queens. According to the New York Post, witnesses saw Pereira flee from the vehicle, fire crawling up the 39-year-old construction worker until he jumped into a pond.

"I have my kid in the car,” the father reportedly said. But when firefighters rushed to the burning sedan, they realized the car was not involved in an accident but a possible crime.

Citing police sources, the New York Post has reported that the girl was strapped into her car seat in the back. The rear doors had been chained shut from the inside to prevent anyone from getting in. Gas was splashed in the interior, and a propane tank in the trunk fed the raging flames.

Freed from the car, Zoey was taken to a hospital, where she was later pronounced dead. Pereira was also taken to a hospital for his injuries and remains in police custody, the Daily News reported. According to Coleman, the fire followed an erratic weekend on which the ill will between the former couple spun out of control.

As the grieving mother told the Daily News on Monday, Pereira had indicated that he was planning to hurt Zoey. “You’ll never see your daughter again,” he allegedly told Coleman hours before the fire.

Authorities have ruled the death a homicide, and the New York Times has reported that investigators think Pereira intentionally set the fire. He had yet to be charged as of Monday night.

A 2017 photo from Pereira’s Facebook page shows the family in happier times: Pereira, bald and with a neat beard beginning to turn gray; Coleman, with black hair trimmed in bangs and a wide smile; and Zoey between her parents, wearing white and a bow holding back her dark hair.

As Angel Rivera, a former co-worker of Pereira, told the New York Times, Pereira had been increasingly agitated since the couple split over the custody fight, thinking that the courts were siding against him and that his daughter was being exposed to marijuana smoke at her mother’s house.

“There was a lot of stress building up in him,” Rivera told the Times. “It made him explode up like that.”

A similar situation played out over the emotionally heated weekend. According to Coleman, Pereira took their daughter to Cohen Children’s Medical Center on Long Island on Saturday. There, he told the staff that Coleman had abused Zoey.

“He was calling me a drug dealer and a drug addict,” Coleman told the Daily News. She denied the allegations to the staff, but he was still allowed to leave the hospital with the girl. “They let him leave with her because he had all the paperwork stating he had visitation,” Coleman said.

On Sunday, Pereira repeatedly kept trying to call Coleman, according to the New York Post. When she did not return his calls, Pereira allegedly called Coleman’s cousins in California and made threatening comments about Zoey.

Coleman then called her ex.

“Just before he burned my daughter, he called saying crazy things,” Coleman told the Daily News. “I couldn’t even understand some of them, but he said, 'Do I have your attention now, b----? I got your attention now, b----. You’re never going to see your daughter again.’"

Coleman responded by calling police, but it was too late. The flaming car was discovered at 8:52 p.m. Sunday, according to Newsday.

“I always thought he was going to hurt me,” she told the Daily News. “I never thought he was going to hurt my daughter.”

More from Morning Mix:

A century-old feud between millionaires is now key to getting Trump’s tax returns

‘Open up the case, period’: Sandra Bland’s family demands answers over new video of her arrest

A ‘sorcerer’ promised to help find love. Instead, he orchestrated a ‘witchcraft extortion scheme.’