During a half-hour of dash-cam footage, the stop appeared routine. Wetzel got Gordon’s information and called a tow truck. The trooper offered to drive Gordon to a car dealership and offered him a mask.
“I can give you a ride wherever you’re trying to go,” Wetzel told Gordon.
After 20 minutes of sitting in the patrol car, Gordon unfastened his seat belt and appeared to get out of the car. Wetzel then yelled “Get in the car” several times while they seemed to tussle outside the cruiser.
The attorney general’s office said Gordon twice tried to enter the driver’s seat of Wetzel’s patrol car. The first time, Wetzel pepper-sprayed him, and during the second instance Wetzel pulled Gordon out of the driver’s seat and, during a struggle, shot him six times.
The time between when Gordon exited the car and when his body collapsed onto the road was more than a minute.
The audio and video recordings are part of the attorney general’s investigation of the use of force. Statewide policy requires such recordings be released once the initial phase of the investigation is substantially complete, typically within 20 days.
But the recordings weren’t shared with Gordon’s family before their public release, according to their attorney, William O. Wagstaff III, who told The Washington Post on Monday that the family was planning the funeral arrangements for Gordon when they got texts from friends and family members about the recordings.
“I just can’t imagine the insensitivity,” Wagstaff said. “They sat on this for two weeks. In the absence of media and the press putting pressure on the state of New Jersey to do the right thing, which is to allow the family to learn the circumstances of Mr. Gordon’s death, they didn’t even give the family a day.”
A spokeswoman for the attorney general’s office said officials offered to show the family the video at their office Sunday and sent a link to the recordings Monday morning before releasing the files to the public.
The video of Gordon’s death comes amid national outrage over the recorded killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, two days after the incident with Gordon. Families of both unarmed black men have demanded the arrest of the officers involved as protests across the country demand accountability for officers who use unnecessary force. Four former police officers have been charged with Floyd’s death and could face up to 40 years in prison if convicted.
At a news briefing Monday, New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy (D) announced that a grand jury would review the case to consider possible criminal charges.
“Police have a responsibility to protect the people they serve, and that demands a high level of accountability when things go wrong,” Murphy said.
Wetzel remains on administrative leave with pay, New Jersey State Police confirmed Monday.
Amid the investigation and promised grand jury review, the family is left with mounting questions about how Gordon was shot during a routine traffic stop.
“I can’t eat, I can’t sleep and just want answers to what happened to my son at 6:30 in the morning,” Gordon’s mother, Racquel Barrett, said as she cried in an interview with the Wall Street Journal. “I don’t know how I’m going to go on in life not hearing his voice.”
Originally from Spanish Town, Jamaica, Gordon was studying chemistry at Dutchess Community College in Poughkeepsie and worked as an Uber driver, Wagstaff said.
In addition to the video of Gordon’s death, the state’s attorney released an audio recording of a 911 call from the day before. A friend of Gordon’s in Poughkeepsie called 911 early in the morning, minutes after Gordon left his home, telling a dispatcher that he was concerned about Gordon’s well-being. He said Gordon had started “to act a little weird” the day before and “said something about a paranormal experience.”
After shooting Gordon, Wetzel radioed emergency communications and requested an ambulance. He told investigators that he thought Gordon was trying to take his gun and car, according to a report obtained by the New York Daily News.
Wagstaff said the framing of the release by the attorney general is questionable.
“They are already rushing to what appears to me to be spin, a narrative to defend the actions of the officer, when you should be arresting the officer,” he said.