The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Texas hostage-taker searched Internet for rabbis, gun shops and Aafia Siddiqui

Law enforcement officers outside Congregation Beth Israel in Colleyville, Tex., a day after the hostage-taking standoff. (Andy Jacobsohn/AFP/Getty Images)
Placeholder while article actions load

A British man conducted Internet searches for influential rabbis, an imprisoned terrorist and gun and pawnshops in the days before he took congregants hostage inside a Texas synagogue, according to law enforcement officials.

FBI agents examining the digital trail left by 44-year-old Malik Faisal Akram have found plenty of evidence hinting at his plan and state of mind in the days before the attack, said the officials, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss the ongoing investigation.

Searches on Akram’s cellphone, they said, led him to focus on Rabbi Angela Buchdahl of New York City’s Central Synagogue, who has been named on various online lists over the past decade as one of the most influential Jewish people in the country.

Akram, who was shot dead by FBI agents after an 11-hour standoff, parroted antisemitic tropes during the hostage-taking, saying he believed Jewish people had the power in the United States to free convicted terrorist Aafia Siddiqui.

Investigators suspect Akram saw Buchdahl mentioned on such lists and came to believe she had the political connections to get his demands to senior U.S. policymakers, officials said. Searches for influential rabbis also led him to focus on his ultimate target: Congregation Beth Israel in the Dallas-Fort Worth suburb of Colleyville.

Texas hostage standoff ends with suspect dead

Over a roughly two-week period in Texas, Akram also searched on his phone for gun shops and pawnshops in the Dallas area, the officials said. But authorities have traced the handgun he used in the attack and think he bought it “on the street” rather than at a business. The gun’s last official sale was recorded in early 2020; it was reported stolen from a hotel room later that year, the officials said.

Akram also looked up online information about Siddiqui, an American-educated Pakistani woman who was convicted in 2010 of trying to kill U.S. soldiers and is serving an 86-year-prison sentence in a federal prison in Texas. Freeing her has become a focus in some Islamist militant circles.

Investigators are still piecing together Akram’s movements in the United States. He arrived at John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York on Dec. 29 and a few days later flew to Dallas, where he stayed at facilities that serve the homeless and got into at least one confrontation at a local mosque, according to law enforcement officials and others familiar with his movements.

On Jan. 1, Akram joined in the day’s last prayer at the Islamic Center of Irving, then asked if he could stay the night, according to Khalid Hamideh, a lawyer and spokesman for the mosque who has watched security footage of the episode and talked to those involved.

Hamideh said a staff member told Akram that city and mosque regulations prevented him from sleeping there, and Akram grew upset, telling staff, “You will be judged by God for not helping a fellow Muslim” and insisting “I’m from a good family.”

Hostage-taker’s English hometown not known for radical fervor

Akram — who was carrying a bag or backpack big enough to hold a weapon — left after the staff member threatened to call police, Hamideh said.

“God knows if he already had acquired the gun and already had the gun in there,” Hamideh said.

“We don’t search anybody,” Hamideh added. “Maybe we’ll start.”

Akram returned about 6 a.m. the next day, Hamideh said. By then, his demeanor had changed.

“This time he was calm, cool, collected,” Hamideh said. “He apologized for his behavior on the previous night and asked for permission just to use the sanctuary to conduct his prayer.”

Hamideh said Akram prayed alone, and left between 7 and 8 a.m. — walking into an empty parking lot. That night, he was dropped off at OurCalling, a Dallas center for homeless people, by a man who escorted him inside and embraced him before saying goodbye, the center’s chief executive has said.

Officials think he also spent time at another area facility for homeless people before knocking on the door of Congregation Beth Israel during Sabbath services the morning of Jan. 15.

After being invited inside and sitting through some of the service, Akram pulled out a gun and took four hostages: Rabbi Charlie Cytron-Walker, congregant Jeffrey Cohen and two others whose names have not been released.

He soon demanded that Cytron-Walker call Buchdahl — who is known for her creative use of music in religious services and was photographed at a White House Hanukkah party during the Obama administration.

“He mentioned her by name, because he knew that she played guitar. . . . He thought that she was the most influential rabbi,” Cytron-Walker said Thursday in an online forum about the hostage-taking that was hosted by the Anti-Defamation League.

Beth Israel hostage: ‘I was not going to let him assassinate us’

Akram wanted Buchdahl specifically to act on his demand that U.S. authorities free Siddiqui. Cytron-Walker reached Buchdahl by phone and relayed Akram’s desires, though both rabbis thought the demand was as far-fetched as it was frightening.

A spokesman for Buchdahl’s synagogue declined to comment.

Speaking at the same online forum, FBI Director Christopher A. Wray said agents are still analyzing and reviewing “phones and other electronic devices and media, and there’s a lot more work to be done.”

“This was not some random occurrence — it was intentional, it was symbolic,” he said. “And we’re not going to tolerate antisemitism in this country.”

The hostage-taking has amplified public concern about security at houses of worship in general and synagogues in particular. On Thursday, Wray said the Texas attack was further evidence that terrorism threats increasingly come from lone actors plotting “fairly simple and unsophisticated — but just as deadly — attacks.”

The challenge for investigators trying to connect the dots to prevent an attack, he added, is “there are a lot fewer dots that connect and a lot less time to connect them.”

‘Being Jewish and alive shouldn’t be a miracle’: World reacts to Texas attack

Law enforcement officials, who are investigating the hostage-taking as a terrorist act, say their portrait of Akram so far suggests Akram was a disturbed individual whose behavior occasionally raised concerns — but not urgent alarms. Officials caution that their understanding could change as they gather more information.

Akram’s relatives have said he had mental health problems. Law enforcement officials said he was known to British security officials, and the BBC reported earlier this week that MI5, Britain’s counterintelligence and security agency, investigated him in 2020 as a “subject of interest” but concluded that he no longer posed a threat.

On Thursday, two men in Manchester, England, were detained for questioning about Akram. Previously, law enforcement officials said, Akram’s teenage children were detained for questioning and released.

Douglas reported from Dallas.

Loading...