Doctors used to routinely remove tonsils — until research found that the pain, risks and costs of the procedure usually outweighed its benefits. While tonsils are more secure now, research suggests that some people may still be getting surgeries they don’t need. Here, four procedures to question if your doctor pushes for them:

Knee surgery

Arthroscopic surgery to trim or remove a torn meniscus — the cartilage that cushions your knees — is the most common orthopedic surgery in the United States. About 700,000 of the procedures are done each year, a 50 percent increase in the past 15 years.

But research shows that it’s often no better than physical therapy at easing symptoms. And in a New England Journal of Medicine study, patients who had sham surgery — in which surgeons made a small incision, then simulated the rest of the procedure — fared just as well as those who had the real deal. Other research shows that arthritis is more likely to develop in people who have the procedure than in those who don’t.

Bottom line: If you’re suffering age-related knee pain and an MRI scan reveals a tear, first try rest, ice, a knee brace, over-the-counter anti-inflammatory drugs and physical therapy.

Carotid artery surgery

Blockages in your carotid arteries — which supply your brain with blood — increase the risk of stroke. So it would seem that surgery to clean out the arteries, with a procedure called carotid endarterectomy, or CEA, would be a good idea. Some doctors agree. They can detect problems by listening with a stethoscope to the blood in those arteries and, if they hear a worrisome sound, ordering an ultrasound.

But if you’re 75 or older, the risks of the procedure — including heart attack and stroke — usually outweigh the benefits. That’s also true for younger people, except for those at very high stroke risk. Yet research suggests that at least 20 percent of patients who undergo CEA aren’t good candidates.

Bottom line: The procedure makes the most sense for people age 40 to 75 who have had a stroke or a ministroke, or are at very high risk of such events. In other cases, ask whether medication and changes to your diet and exercise habits would be a better option.

Spinal fusion

As we age, overgrowth of the bone surrounding the spinal canal can pinch nerves and cause a burning pain in your buttocks that radiates down your leg. A common treatment for that condition, called spinal stenosis, eases pressure by removing part of the bone and tissue.

Many surgeons combine that procedure, called laminectomy, with another one, called spinal fusion, which is meant to stabilize the spine. The number of fusion procedures jumped 67 percent among Medicare patients between 2001 and 2011.

But for most people, there’s no evidence that adding fusion works better than performing laminectomy alone. Fusion also carries more risks and costs more. There’s a good chance, in fact, that you don’t need any surgery. In a study published in April, patients who had physical therapy did as well as surgery patients.

Bottom line: If you have spinal stenosis, try six to eight weeks of physical therapy before considering surgery. If surgery does become necessary, choose laminectomy, unless you have a slipped vertebra or scoliosis (curvature of the spine).


New therapies, including progesterone IUDs and uterine artery embolization, have made hysterectomy less common as a treatment for uterine fibroids and the heavy bleeding those growths can cause. Still, about 18 percent of hysterectomies done for noncancerous reasons are unnecessary, according to a 2014 study. When a hysterectomy is needed, some surgeons still remove the uterus through a large abdominal incision, not vaginally, though that approach and newer ones are usually preferable.

Bottom line: Make sure nonsurgical options have been considered. If you opt for a hysterectomy, ask for a vaginal or minimally invasive form of the procedure.

Copyright 2015. Consumers Union of United States Inc.

For further guidance, go to www.ConsumerReports.org/Health, where more detailed information, including CR’s ratings of prescription drugs, treatments, hospitals and healthy-living products, is available to subscribers.