Proponents say it gives parents more options and power in their children’s education. Opponents say it is a stealth way of turning traditional public schools into charter schools and that it will lead to more privately run schools and contentious battles in school communities (such as the one that ripped up the California town of Adelanto).
The Florida Senate’s former Democratic leader, Nan Rich of Weston, who is running for governor in 2014, said at a recent press conference that the bill is really about “laying the groundwork for the hostile, corporate takeover of public schools throughout Florida” and is “a direct attack on public education.”
The Florida legislation, which failed last year, has already passed in the state House and will be taken up by the Senate by the end of the month. In an effort to make it more appealing to opponents, an amendment changed the language in the Senate version to allow the local school board to make the final decision after parents petition for a change in school leadership. That move, according to this piece by Orlando Sentinel columnist Beth Kassab, stripped the bill of much of ts power, but critics say it still has damaging provisions, including one that allows converted charters to be be exempt from state class-size laws.
Who is for it and who is against it tells the real parent trigger story.
- Walton Family Foundation
- Gates Foundation
- Broad Foundation
- California Education Policy Fund Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors
- Rogers Family Foundation
- Emerson Collective Education Fund
- The Sheri and Les Biller Family Foundation
- Silicon Valley Community Foundation
- Laura and John Arnold Foundation
- East Bay Community Foundation
- Wasserman Foundation
And here, among others, are the organizations against the parent trigger legislation:
- Florida PTA
- Florida NAACP
- League of Women Voters
- Citizens for Strong Schools
- League of United Latin American Citizens
- National Jewish Women’s Council
- Parents Across America
- Fund Education Florida
- 50th No More
- Save Duval Schools
- Support Dade Schools
- Marion’s United for Public Education
So it’s a powerful coalition of super-wealthy foundations — virtually none of them are based in Florida — against Florida-based citizens and parents groups.
Here’s the bottom line: If the Florida PTA, the famous Parent Teachers Association, doesn’t support it, can parent trigger really be the parent empowerment bill that supporters claim it is?