The critique came in response to a question from Fox News anchor Anna Kooiman, who appeared to suggest hypocrisy on Beyoncé's part:
"Beyoncé got a police escort there, and then she gives a salute to the Black Lives Matter movement. … It was a nod to 1966 founding of the Black Panther Party. What did you think of that?" Kooiman asked.
"I think it was outrageous. The halftime show I thought was ridiculous anyway," Giuliani said shortly before launching into his defense of police.
He wasn't alone in finding her performance divisive — other conservatives took issue with it as well.
The performance carried a strong theme of black empowerment, featuring Beyoncé flanked by women dressed in what was clearly a nod to the fashion of the Black Panther Party of the 1960s and 1970s. At one point, her crew of backup dancers formed an X, which some interpreted as a reference to civil rights leader Malcolm X.
Marni Senofonte, who styled Beyoncé for the show, offered insight into Beyoncé's sartorial choice in an interview with Essence magazine:
It was important to her to honor the beauty of strong black women and celebrate the unity that fuels their power. One of the best examples of that is the image of the female Black Panther. The women of the Black Panther Party created a sisterhood and worked right alongside their men fighting police brutality and creating community social programs. That they started here in the Bay Area, where the Super Bowl is being held this year, was not lost on her. And they made a fashion statement with natural afros, black leather jackets and black pant suits. That image of women in leadership roles; believing they are a vital part of the struggle is undeniably provocative and served as reference and reality.
In his appearance on Monday, Giuliani criticized the move as political and called for "decent, wholesome entertainment."
Although he and others considered the performance an affront to and an attack on police, others praised it for sending an empowering message to a long-aggrieved group.
CORRECTION: An earlier version of this article incorrectly stated Giuliani's previous political aspirations. He was a onetime Republican presidential contender.