So how did this year’s big political comedy moment come to be? It all started with an airplane pitch about a monologue to Kristen Stewart, McCarthy explained to The Hollywood Reporter.
McCarthy was headed to New York for a movie shoot, while Stewart was en route for her SNL hosting gig. “She has a reputation for not loving to be interviewed, which I think becomes very funny, so I shamelessly pitched her [this monologue idea where she’s] doing the worst opening ever,” McCarthy told THR for their cover story about SNL’s “yuuuge year.”
At the same time, SNL writers had been watching Spicer’s first few press briefings. “They were just so insane,” writer Kent Sublette told THR. “It was a Tuesday, and one of our producers, Erik Kenward, told me that Melissa had flown out with our host and had a monologue idea. That’s when I just blurted out, ‘Melissa should play Spicer.’”
In that lead-up to that moment, many people had lamented that they wished Chris Farley was still around to play Spicer, Kenward told the outlet.
“In a lot of ways, Melissa is the closest thing just in terms of sheer power and comedy physicality that we have to Chris Farley, and I knew Lorne felt the same way,” Kenward said. “I called him and he immediately was like, ‘Absolutely. Let’s make it happen.’”
Sublette, who’s friends with McCarthy from the Los Angeles-based Groundlings, knew the comedian would be okay playing a man and being outrageous on camera. In fact, McCarthy played Farley’s famed “Matt Foley” character on SNL for the 2015 40th anniversary episode. When she appeared on “Weekend Update,” Fey introduced her: “Oh, it’s just Melissa McCarthy doing her favorite character!”
There was still a problem. “I don’t do impressions. I don’t have the ear for it,” McCarthy said. “But when I read the script, I was like, ‘Oh, God, that is juicy, but I don’t understand how we’re going to physically make it work.’ To which the amazing special effects person at SNL was like, “Oh, yeah, that’s not that big of a deal. That’s gonna take me, like, 15 minutes.” I was like, ‘Hey!’”
Sublette told her “it was more about the attitude — the bombast and the anger.”
McCarthy told THR she was “so nervous” playing Spicer for the first time:
It was very quiet at first, and I’m thinking, “The audience is already turning before they even know what’s going on.” There was this weird, great delay, and first people figure out it’s Spicer and then they figure out it’s me. You could just feel it in the room. And then I get off, and I have all of these texts, like “Oh, my God, are you looking at what’s happening?” I didn’t quite know what to do with the reaction.
The sketch was a big hit, even overshadowing chatter about Alec Baldwin’s Trump impersonation that week.
“Well,” McCarthy recalled, “once I heard ‘motorized podium’ and ‘jewelry,’ I said, ‘Can he also be wearing a shoe?’”
The impersonation still draws viewers. An estimated 10.3 million viewers tuned in Saturday, making the McCarthy-hosted episode SNL’s highest-rated May edition in seven years, according to overnight preliminary ratings numbers from Nielsen released Sunday. For this season, only Alec Baldwin’s turn as host on Feb. 11 had more viewers (McCarthy also played Spicer on that show, too).
Sublette told THR that the show didn’t have a shortage of potential “Spicers.”
“If it hadn’t been Melissa, it would have gone to Beck [Bennett]. He has an amazing impression,” Sublette said. “In fact, he reads Spicer for the read-through because Melissa’s not usually there.”