During the day-long event, volunteers and visitors took turns stirring the apple butter with wooden paddles continuously for 10 to 12 hours. That’s a lot of stirring! The wooden paddles had very long handles to ensure the boiling brew didn’t splatter up onto the arms of those stirring the pot.
After cooking, the apple butter was poured into canning jars and prepared for sale. The apple butter produced during the celebration is usually sold out on the same day it’s made, even before the jars finish cooling. It’s very good, and it’s very popular!
David Foltz, who supervised the cooking of the apple butter, told me that the recipe used on Saturday has been passed down in his family through multiple generations and is at least 100 years old. I asked David whether he would share his family recipe with us, and he was more than happy to disclose all of the buttery details. A word of warning, however: This recipe calls for an open wood fire and a 40-gallon copper pot.
Apple Butter Ingredients
- 9 bushels of golden and red delicious apples –peeled, cored and finely sliced
- 50 lbs. of sugar
- 13 teaspoons of cinnamon oil
- 3 gallons of apple cider
- Pour the apple cider into a 40-gallon copper kettle and place over an open wood fire.
- Add the sliced apples and sugar into the copper kettle.
- Add the cinnamon oil.
- Cook for 10 to 12 hours while stirring continuously.
- Serve or can when the mixture is thick and dark brown.
Since many of us can’t prepare David’s family recipe at home, here’s a link to an old-fashioned apple butter recipe that will scale to your kitchen: All-day Apple Butter.
The event also included music, dancing, pony rides, locally made wine and cider, and plenty of food. Skyland is located at mile 42 on Skyline Drive, where the views are terrific. Despite the warm temperatures, there was a definite feeling of fall at the event. The smell of wood smoke, cooking apples and cinnamon helped set the mood. Also, the trees at the top of the Blue Ridge Mountains are starting to show a hint of fall color.
The Apple Butter Celebration is held on National Park Service property and is run by Delaware North. Helen Morton, sales director, and Nick Smith, general manager, of Delaware North said this was the event’s 18th year. There is also a blackberry event that is held in July at Skyland called Blackberry Delight, but it’s not quite as large and popular as the Apple Butter Celebration.
If you missed Saturday’s festival, Berkeley Springs, W.Va., will hold its downtown Apple Butter Festival during the weekend of Oct. 7-8. Capon Springs resort will also produce apple butter in October.
Let us know your favorite apple butter recipes, stories or events, and tell us your favorite way of serving apple butter. For me, I love to make peanut butter and apple butter sandwiches. I also toast bread, spread on a lot of butter, then add a thick layer of apple butter. I’ll even eat apple butter out of the jar with a spoon. But I don’t double dip — really.
Stirring apple butter at the Apple Butter Celebration (Kevin Ambrose)