The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Now that we’ve seen Tom Hardy’s Venom, do we want to see the movie more or less?

Tom Hardy stars as Venom. (Sony)
Placeholder while article actions load

There is perhaps no bigger comic book-inspired cinematic enigma than Sony’s “Venom” movie, which will arrive in theaters this October.

After a seemingly pointless teaser trailer release in February that had plenty of star Tom Hardy but absolutely no Venom, the grumbling began as to whether Sony, which needed Marvel Studios to save Spider-Man on film, could be trusted to spin off a new Marvel movie franchise by itself.

Tom Hardy’s first ‘Venom’ trailer gives us everything — except Venom

That first teaser likely served as a gentle reminder to the comic book movie faithful that yes, this movie is actually being made. For the first full trailer, which debuted in late April, Sony was going to have to bring it with a Venom money shot.

And it delivered.

It took until the final moments of the trailer, but there was Hardy, rising from the ground, in black, symbiotic ooze with creepy all-white eyes, instantly going from prey to predator.

There he is. Venom. One of Spider-Man’s most popular villains, brought to life by the ’90s comic book artwork of artists such as Todd McFarlane, Erik Larson and Mark Bagley. The seconds’-worth of a glance we get, after he declares “We are Venom” in a ghoulishly dark voice, instantly pass the comic-book geek visual test.

But do we have a hit franchise here? It’s just too soon to tell.

Sony and “Venom” will have to overcome the stigma of being a Marvel movie without the guidance of Marvel Studios, something 20th Century Fox knows all too well. In “Deadpool,” which has a sequel dropping this month, Fox struck gold with a raunchy, R-rated hit that stayed true to its comic book roots while also taking the superhero movie to a place that it hadn’t been before, stylistically. But Fox’s “X-Men” franchise, with 2014’s “Days of Future Past” and 2016’s “Apocalypse” as recent outings, feels like it’s on its last leg and could use a Marvel Studios infusion.

“Venom” has two options. It can go the “Deadpool” route, creating something that feels new with a highly fan-recognizable comic book property, embracing the opportunity to make some comic-book inspired horror with a character that’s hella scary. Or the movie could come off like those Andrew Garfield “Amazing Spider-Man” movies: good, not great, and seemingly made just to hold onto a character’s movie rights.

Hardy has already given an all-time super-villain performance as Bane in 2012’s “The Dark Knight Rises.” Can he be just as convincing as an anti-hero? He certainly looks a lot more like Venom alter-ego Eddie Brock, bringing way more bulk than Topher Grace did when he played the character in 2007’s “Spider-Man 3.” And Venom actually talking and not just screeching like he did in “Spider-Man 3” is already a major improvement from what we’ve seen before on the screen.

A good villain could make the difference in this film. There’s a whole lot of symbiotes (the elements that make up the black alien goo that turns Brock into Venom) in this movie. So Hardy might not be the only person wearing a symbiotic suit that turns him into a super-strong monster. If Carnage (think a red and black and even more lethal version of Venom) is the antagonist of “Venom,” as rumored, that could provide the visuals that could get fans lighting up social media with the type of buzz this movie needs to be successful. Sony will have to decide whether to play that card and reveal him at this year’s San Diego Comic Con, or leave it as a surprise for fans when they see the movie.

“Venom” has a chance to give Sony some much-needed independence from Marvel Studios. With the rights to so many Spider-Man-universe characters, Sony could prove it’s still got a little comic book magic left. Or this could be the movie that leads fans to demand Marvel Studios take over everything Marvel related on film.

Here’s hoping Sony gets it right. A successful “Venom” movie could lead to crossovers against Holland’s Spider-Man (something many fans want to see if Venom is around), and show that everything Marvel doesn’t have to connect to an Infinity Stone or Deadpool.

Read more:

Here’s what makes ‘Avengers: Infinity War’ so special. It’s not the gathering of superheroes.

All six Spider-Man movies, ranked from best to worst