The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

School district apologizes after students told ‘Make America Great Again’ shirts not allowed in class

President Trump speaks at a “Make America Great Again” rally in Phoenix on Aug. 22. (Nicholas Kamm/AFP/Getty Images)
Placeholder while article actions load

A Georgia school district has apologized after one of its teachers asked two high school students wearing “Make America Great Again” T-shirts to leave her classroom.

The incident took place at River Ridge High School on Aug. 31, when a teacher “erroneously told two students their shirts with campaign slogans were not permitted in class,” Cherokee County School District spokeswoman Barbara P. Jacoby said.

“Her actions were wrong, as the ‘Make America Great Again’ shirts worn by the students are not a violation of our School District dress code,” Jacoby said in a statement. “The teacher additionally — and inappropriately — shared her personal opinion about the campaign slogan during class.”

Classes at the school in Woodstock, Ga., about 30 miles north of Atlanta, had started Aug. 1. It is unclear who reported the incident to the teacher’s supervisors, although student video of the exchange soon began circulating on social media, according to the International Business Times.

The principal at River Ridge “immediately met with and apologized to these students and their families,” Jacoby said. She added that district Superintendent Brian V. Hightower was “deeply sorry that this incident happened in one of our schools; it does not reflect his expectation that all students be treated equally and respectfully by our employees.”

On Tuesday, the local Patch news site reported that Hightower sent a message to school system employees saying that they are prohibited from sharing their personal political opinions with students when they are performing their job duties.

Shortly after the incident, someone started a petition calling for the teacher in question to resign. The district did not identify the teacher and said it could not discuss disciplinary action taken against an employee. However, Jacoby noted the students who wore the shirts faced no disciplinary action.

“The Superintendent also is instructing all Principals to meet with their teachers and staff to review the dress code and remind them that their political opinions should not be shared with students,” she said.

This school staged a ‘Color Wars’ pep rally. Then students showed up in ‘White Pride’ shirts.

The incident drew sharp criticism from some Georgia officials.

“It’s just shocking — you can’t do that to kids,” state Rep. Earl Ehrhart (R) told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution. “That’s so wrong on so many levels. That individual doesn’t need to be anywhere near a classroom ever again.”

State Rep. John Carson (R), whose district includes River Ridge High School, told the newspaper in an email it was attempt to silence conservative free speech.

It’s not the first time a school has drawn controversy over action taken against political displays in the classroom.

Last August, Mariah Havard wore a shirt emblazoned with “Black Lives Matter” to picture day at her high school in Buckeye, Ariz. In a widely shared Facebook post, Havard said she was told her shirt was “disruptive in a learning environment” and was asked to change into a plain white T-shirt. A week later, after another student at the school was asked to remove a “Black Lives Matter” shirt, a small group of students staged a walkout over the incidents.

“We’re not trying to start a race war,” Genesis Santoyo, Havard’s friend, told the Arizona Republic. “We’re trying to end one.”

i woke up this very morning knowing that it's picture day for my school we all know as Buckeye Union High School – BUHSD…

Posted by Mariah Havard on Tuesday, August 23, 2016

During the presidential campaign, Grant Berardo, then a high school junior in central New Jersey, wore a “TRUMP Make American Great Again!” shirt on picture day. When his yearbook arrived, however, he noticed his photo had been edited so the campaign slogan was missing, leaving a plain black shirt. Outraged, Berardo’s parents accused Wall Township public schools of censorship. At least two other students there, including Wyatt Dobrovich-Fago and his sister, Montana, had similar experiences:

In a statement, the superintendent of the Wall Township school district said they were “equally outraged” and did not condone the “disturbing” yearbook edits. The high school’s yearbook adviser was later suspended, and the incident even caught the attention of the president himself.

“Thank you Wyatt and Montana — two young Americans who aren’t afraid to stand up for what they believe in. Our movement to #MAGA is working because of great people like you!” Trump wrote on Facebook. The post also noted the students had received more “Make America Great Again” paraphernalia.

Thank you Wyatt and Montana — two young Americans who aren’t afraid to stand up for what they believe in. Our movement to #MAGA is working because of great people like you!

Posted by Donald J. Trump on Monday, June 19, 2017

Read more:

A book about a dress-loving boy was supposed to teach kids acceptance — until lawmakers complained

A teacher’s solution to buy school supplies for her classroom: Panhandling

Teachers gave a teen with ADHD a ‘Most Likely to Not Pay Attention’ award