The Washington Post

Poll: Paul McCartney’s best Beatles song

We all know which Paul McCartney songs are our favorites. Easy. But have you ever tried ranking them? Hard. Really hard. Yank-all-of your-old-LPs-off-the-shelf-and-watch-three-hours-of-your-life-vanish hard.

• Paul McCartney tour hits Nationals Park on Friday | Setlist surprises?

(Tracy A. Woodward / The Washington Post)

After lots of toe-tapping agony, I came up with this list of my top nine McCartney-penned Beatles tunes, and my one favorite side of a Wings album.

1. “Hey Jude.” Perhaps not the most original pick, but this is my list so “na-na-na-nya-nya-nya-nya.”
2. “We Can Work It Out.” One of those rare 50/50 collaborations with Lennon and pure ecstasy to me.
3. “Eleanor Rigby.” It scared me as a child.
4. “Carry That Weight.” What a singalong.
5. “Let It Be.” It delighted me as a child – at first on Sesame Street as “Letter B.”
6. “Helter Skelter.” The sound of a nice boy being nasty.
7. “All My Loving.” A young lesson: love is so much happy-sadness.
8. “Yesterday.” Aw.
9. “Good Day Sunshine.” The cutest one from the cute one?

And that best Wings album side: Side A of “Band on the Run.” What a suite. Once it goes on my turntable, it doesn’t come off until the outro guitar squiggles of “Let Me Roll With It” fade to silence.

Chris Richards is The Washington Post's pop music critic. He has recently written about David Bowie's legacy of reinvention, Beyoncé's Super Bowl victory, viral go-go covers and rock star death waves.
Show Comments

To keep reading, please enter your email address.

You’ll also receive from The Washington Post:
  • A free 6-week digital subscription
  • Our daily newsletter in your inbox

Please enter a valid email address

I have read and agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Please indicate agreement.

Thank you.

Check your inbox. We’ve sent an email explaining how to set up an account and activate your free digital subscription.