“This was an effort to kill someone, not a mistake by hitting someone too hard,” Bohren said, ABC affiliate WISN reported.
Advocates of criminal-justice reform have kept a close eye on the case and believe the girls should be treated by the system as minors. “Anything else is legal fiction,” National Juvenile Defender Center director Kim Dvorchak told the Journal Sentinel before Bohren’s decision.
The horrific 2014 stabbing attracted national attention in part because of its connection to the Slender Man, a mythological creature and Internet meme born out of an obscure online forum in 2009. The girls told authorities that they hatched a plot to kill a friend during a birthday slumber party in May 2014to prove their loyalty to Slender Man; they also said Slender Man had threatened their families, according to the criminal complaint.
Geyser and Weier were 12 years old at the time of the alleged attack; a passerby found the victim bleeding in a wooded park, and the girl survived.
Shortly after the stabbing, authorities found Geyser and Weier walking toward Nicolet National Forest, where they said they hoped to join Slender Man in his mansion. One of the girls had a five-inch blade knife in her backpack, according to the criminal complaint.
The girls were initially charged as adults, per Wisconsin law. Prosecutors also argued that the girls behaved like adults in spending months in plotting the killing of their friend, which they described in court filings as “a very adult offense,” adding that the girls “should remain in adult court to face the consequences.”
Lawyers for Geyser and Weier presented arguments during two separate hearings earlier this year in an effort to get them returned to juvenile court, where they could have received a maximum sentence of five years. If convicted in adult court, they would remain in a juvenile facility until they turned 18. The girls would receive better mental health treatment in the juvenile system than in the adult system, their attorneys argued.
Geyser was diagnosed with early onset schizophrenia during court competency evaluations, and she still believes in the existence of the mythological Slender Man and fictional characters such as Harry Potter. She is opposed to taking medication because she believes it would stop her ability to talk with these “friends,” the Journal Sentinel reported.
Geyser’s attorneys argued that their client’s condition would worsen in adult prison, the Associated Press reported. She “is not the hardened, irascible offender who… needs to be taught a lesson through adult court placement,” attorney Anthony Cotton wrote in court filings.
Experts testified during a May hearing that Weier had a delusional disorder in 2014, that she is remorseful and that she wants to get better. Both the stabbing victim and Weier told authorities that Geyser did the stabbing, the Journal Sentinel reported.
The defense had to clear a number of hurdles in order to get their clients’ cases transferred to the juvenile system, including proving that moving them wouldn’t “depreciate the seriousness of the offense.” Reporters in the courtroom tweeted the judge’s reasoning as he delivered his decision:
Both defendants will be arraigned on Aug. 21, according to court records.