The medical field was receptive to his findings. It remained so. As recently as 2008, textbooks like the 40th edition of “Gray’s Anatomy” echoed descriptions that Treves presented in his lectures. But Treves’s research contained an error that persisted for more than a century, wrote a pair of scientists in the Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology journal, published in November but spotted recently by the Independent: Treves neglected to give the mesentery, a double sheet of connective tissue that curls through the abdomen, the importance it deserved, as an organ.
Treves declared that the mesentery existed only sporadically, in disjointed ribbons, dispersed among the intestines and therefore did not meet the definition of an organ; an organ, broadly speaking, must be a self-contained structure that performs a specific bodily function.
That the mesentery was so divided was not correct, the researchers wrote in the new report. “The anatomic description that had been laid down over 100 years of anatomy was incorrect. This organ is far from fragmented and complex,” said J. Calvin Coffey, a study author and surgeon at the University of Limerick, Ireland, in a statement. “It is simply one continuous structure.”
The mesentery, argued the scientists from University of Limerick, in Ireland, was not separate sections of connective wrap. As a single entity, it could be classified as an organ. (By most counts, tissues of the human body are lumped into 78 organs. The mesentery, then, would be No. 79.) “We are now saying we have an organ in the body which hasn’t been acknowledged as such to date,” Coffey said.
Next to the thumping heart and the brain’s enigmatic mass, the mesentery may seem like a humble thing. It is a fatty membrane that holds the intestines in place. Though the classification as an organ is new, the mesentery itself is not a contemporary discovery; what appears to be the mesentery can be seen in a drawing by Leonardo da Vinci.
The metaphors the mesentery inspires are a far cry from stomach butterflies or broken hearts. If you were to imagine the guts as dress fabric, as 19th century physician Worthington Hooker did in his book “Human Physiology,” the mesentery would be a ruffle encircling the “puffed edging” of the intestines.
Without the mesentery, though, bound on one end to the backbone, the intestines would slop around in the belly. Coffey and his colleagues confirmed the mesentery was continuous, stretching from the rectum to the small intestine at the base of the stomach, in a series of studies in 2012 and 2014. After revealing its structure, the scientists argued they had enough evidence to “justify designation of the mesentery as an organ.” Coffey went as far as to argue life without the mesentery is impossible — “without it you can’t live,” he said to Discover Magazine.
If there existed a scientific organization charged with naming the organs, it was unclear even to surgeons such as Coffey. (“I actually don’t know who the final arbiter of that is,” he told Discover. Coffey could not be reached for comment early Wednesday.) But, typically, anatomists classify organs not only by their continuity but also by a common function. The complete function of the mesentery remains a mystery.
“Many, but not all, organs have a distinct functional unit,” the researchers wrote in the Lancet report. “The functional unit of the mesentery is unknown, and whether a distinctive cell type is primarily responsible for its functionality should be investigated.”
Nor do the researchers know whether doctors should view the body part as belonging to the intestinal system, they wrote, or if it would be better classified as part of the vascular system, the endocrine system or another system altogether. Perhaps it does not fit neatly into one. Evidence suggests that the mesentery is more than a connector, too; the mesentery may regulate the migration of white blood cells throughout the intestines, the scientists wrote.
Coffey hoped that shining a light on a body part not normally so exposed could widen the field of mesenteric science, offering a new target in the fight against gut diseases like Crohn’s. In places, it appears a change, however small, has already begun: The mesentery, noted the study’s authors, was described as continuous in the 41st and most recent edition of “Gray’s Anatomy.”