The Washington Post

Woman arrested in Craigslist ‘rape fantasy’ plot was framed in a ‘diabolical scheme,’ DA says


Michelle Susan Hadley, right, hugs Orange County District Attorney Chief of Staff Susan Kang Schroeder after being cleared of all charges in a complicated plot to frame her in Fullerton, Calif., on, Jan. 9, 2017. (Jeff Gritchen/Orange County Register via AP)

In the often-lewd world of online forums and classified listings, a horrifying phenomenon exists: men who post advertisements for “rape fantasies,” soliciting women who are willing to engage in sex resembling rape.

Some of these ads appeared on Craigslist last year, and on a number of occasions, in Southern California. A woman identified as Angela Diaz responded. She sent photos of herself and details about her daily routine, telling some of the men that she wanted them to have “forcible sexual intercourse with her, even if she screamed or resisted.”

And the men began showing up at her condo. On one occasion, she called the police to report an attempted rape, and officers arrived to find visible redness on her neck and breasts, her shirt ripped.

She told police she had not, in fact, posted the messages on Craigslist. She told them they were actually posted by someone posing as her, her husband’s ex-girlfriend, Michelle Hadley.

Police investigated and decided she was telling the truth. In July, in a story that made national headlines, Hadley was arrested for posing as Diaz on Craigslist in an attempt to get men to attack her. Hadley, of Ontario, Calif., was charged with multiple felonies, including stalking, criminal threats and attempted forcible rape, facing a life sentence in prison if convicted.

But months later, in a bizarre turn in an already bizarre story, authorities discovered the allegations against Hadley were all false. Diaz had made them up in an effort to frame Hadley, they alleged. Hadley was an “innocent victim of a diabolical scheme” meticulously planned and executed by her ex-fiancée’s new wife, Diaz, the Orange County District Attorney’s Office said Monday.

Prosecutors exonerated Hadley of all charges, and instead charged Diaz with kidnapping, false imprisonment, perjury and other crimes. If convicted, Diaz, 31, of Phoenix faces a maximum sentence of 12 years and eight months in state prison plus 11 years in county jail.

“It’s often said that true life is stranger than fiction,” District Attorney Tony Rackauckas said in a news conference Monday. “The facts of this case make that statement spot on.”


Angela Maria Diaz, left, and Michelle Hadley, right. (Courtesy of Orange County District Attorney’s Office)

The two women are linked by a man named Ian Diaz, an agent with the U.S. Marshals Service, the Associated Press reported. According to court records, Diaz dated Hadley in Anaheim, Calif., from 2013 to 2015 before marrying Angela Diaz, who is originally from Arizona. Prosecutors said they have no evidence he was involved.

A motive for the alleged scheme was not clear to prosecutors, but Rackauckas speculated it had something to do with a “love triangle” and “wanting to put the dagger into the older relationship,” he said.

All of the evidence had originally pointed at Hadley, including threatening emails seemingly sent to Angela Diaz from Hadley’s verified address, using language and “religious tones” that mirrored previous emails she had sent to her ex-boyfriend. In the emails, Hadley appeared to threaten Diaz’ life and that of her unborn child, sending her links to graphic images of decapitated bodies and aborted fetuses.

Prosecutors say Diaz actually sent the emails to herself, using virtual private networks and third-party servers to make it appear that Hadley had sent them. It took investigators “months of painstaking work to remove the disguise of the IP addresses,” Rackauckas said. Authorities ultimately discovered the messages had actually originated from Diaz’ condo, her cellphone and her father’s home in Arizona.

“That was the real ‘aha’ moment,” said Deputy District Attorney Richard Zimmer.

Along with attempting to frame Hadley, Diaz is accused of faking a pregnancy and cervical cancer, forging doctor’s notes, posing as an attorney and as two of her husband’s ex-girlfriends, and forging a check.

Zimmer said that while Diaz gave the impression of “an upper-middle-class professional,” the investigation revealed her to be “a serial con artist,” the Los Angeles Times reported.

“I’m not afraid to say she duped me,” Zimmer said. “She duped us. It was very sophisticated, well thought-out.”

Diaz was arrested in Phoenix on Friday and is awaiting extradition from Arizona. She faces felony charges including kidnapping; false imprisonment by menace, fraud or deceit; perjury; grand theft; and forgery, and multiple misdemeanor counts of falsely reporting crimes to law enforcement.

Her kidnapping charge was rooted in Diaz’ successful attempt to get Hadley arrested and taken to jail, Rackauckas said.

Hadley was first arrested in June 2016 on the day Diaz reported the attempted rape. She posted bail but was arrested again three weeks later after Diaz reported she continued to receive threatening messages, and after a 17-year-old boy arrived at Diaz’s home in response to the Craigslist ad.

Hadley spent 88 days in jail, held on $1 million bail. As evidence mounted that she was innocent, she was released in October.

Her lawyer, Michael Guisti, said Michelle Hadley was simply a 29-year-old student pursuing a master’s degree in business administration when the accusations were made. To be exonerated by the district attorney was “a huge relief” for her, Guisti said.

During a brief hearing Monday, prosecutors officially dropped the charges against her, and a judge told her she was “free to go.”

Hadley cried, smiled and hugged relatives, the Los Angeles Times reported.

“This has been a huge nightmare for me,” Hadley told reporters, “probably the most traumatic experience of my life.”

Diaz could not be located for comment by the Associated Press.

More from Morning Mix

Backpage.com shuts down adult services ads after relentless pressure from authorities

‘I can lift my head again': 68 years later, undesirable discharge of gay vet, 91, is overturned

Cleveland Clinic doc pens viral screed against vaccines, peers call it ‘post-truth medicine’

80+
Comments
86
Show Comments
0 Comments
Washington Post Subscriptions

Get 2 months of digital access to The Washington Post for just 99¢.

A limited time offer for Apple Pay users.

Buy with
Cancel anytime

$9.99/month after the two month trial period. Sales tax may apply.
By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service, Digital Products Terms of Sale & Privacy Policy.

Get 2 months of digital access to The Washington Post for just 99¢.

Sign up for email updates from the "Confronting the Caliphate" series.

You have signed up for the "Confronting the Caliphate" series.

Thank you for signing up
You'll receive e-mail when new stories are published in this series.
Most Read

national

morning-mix

Success! Check your inbox for details.

See all newsletters

Close video player
Now Playing
Read content from allstate
Content from Allstate This content is paid for by an advertiser and published by WP BrandStudio. The Washington Post newsroom was not involved in the creation of this content. Learn more about WP BrandStudio.
We went to the source. Here’s what matters to millennials.
A state-by-state look at where Generation Y stands on the big issues.