Eight years ago, amid the financial collapse known as the Great Recession, America broke up with its 43rd president with such relief it might as well have dumped his clothes on the White House lawn and screamed from an open window “get out!”
In 2008, at the close of his second term, President George W. Bush’s approval ratings had plunged to 25 percent, among the lowest in presidential history next to Harry Truman and Richard Nixon. His would-be Republican successor, candidate John McCain, actively distanced himself from the Bush administration and comedians relentlessly mocked the man.
So during his presidential “afterlife,” as his wife calls it, the eight years of America’s rebound relationship with cool guy Barack Obama, Bush eased into an existence of purposeful inconspicuousness. He wrote a book, as most past presidents do, learned to paint and said nothing controversial.
He left former aides to defend Bush, the legacy, and Bush, the man. Most of those who worked with him loved him and deeply resented his vilification by critics during and after his time and office.
There’s no evidence of any substantive reappraisal of Bush by those critics, who remain incensed by, among other things, the fact that he took the nation to war in Iraq over weapons of mass destruction that did not exist.
But in the first few months of 2017 and amid a book tour that landed him glowing spots on the “Ellen DeGeneres Show” and in People magazine, Bush is at least getting a little more respect from some who deeply disrespected him.
Time helped. So did President Trump.
Some of the rethinking of Bush stems not from anything Bush has said or done but simply from the contrast with President Trump, a comparison bolstered by his recent appearances on talk shows and in news segments.
After the “Ellen” show posted a video of the former president joking about his inner “Rembrandt” and learning to paint, viewers flooded the comments with unexpected praise.
“A few years ago I would have rolled my eyes at the [sight] of this man, but 6 weeks of Trump makes W look like a pretty decent guy,” one woman wrote. “Perspective is a funny thing.”
Added another: “I used to be a big critic of him and still don’t agree with much of what he did while in office. But, given who is now in office and how scary 45 is making the world, I’ve come to actually like this man.”
George W. Bush: hero of the left.
— Rick Hasen (@rickhasen) February 27, 2017
It was an idea comedian Aziz Ansari explored in January during his monologue as host of “Saturday Night Live,” the same show that spent years writing unflattering skits of President Bush and has since turned its humor to a new GOP target.
“George W Bush made a speech after 9/11, and it really helped,” Ansari said. “Things changed. … He said Islam is peace.”
The monologue came one day after Trump’s inaugural address, which took on a dark and menacing tone, echoing his campaign rhetoric, which was often critical of Muslims and immigrants.
Ansari compared Trump’s language to that of Bush in 2001, when he walked shoeless through the Islamic Center of Washington six days after Islamist terrorists flew planes into the Pentagon and World Trade Center, killing thousands of people. Flanked by Muslim men and women, the president delivered a unifying speech that was praised by both parties and skyrocketed his approval ratings.
“It was about basic human decency and remembering why the country was founded in the first place,” Ansari said.
And, by his own admission, the comic said he realized he had found himself in a perplexing position.
“What the hell has happened?” he said during the monologue. “I’m sitting here wistfully watching old George W. Bush speeches?’ Just sitting there like, ‘What a leader he was! … He guided us with his eloquence!’”
And some of the praise is backhanded, as per an editorial in the Guardian suggesting that “he sounds a lot better out of office than in it.”
But some onetime critics, who would never have credited Bush with wisdom, are now looking to Bush for just that. And to a large extent, he has delivered, appearing to criticize Trump in a way he never did Obama.
In an interview with “Today’s” Matt Lauer, for example, Bush defended the news media against Trump’s “enemies of the American people” attack.
“We needed the media to hold people like me to account,” said Bush. “Power can be very addictive and it can be corrosive, and it’s important for the media to call to account people who abuse their power.”
“I think we all need answers,” he said, when asked about Russia’s attempt to intervene in the election through hacking. Asked whether there should be a special prosecutor, he said “I’m not sure the right avenue to take. I am sure, though, that that question needs to be answered.”
Bush later said he didn’t intend for his comments to be construed as criticism of Trump.
Joy Behar, the liberal on the daily talk show “The View,” noted after Bush’s comments that though she was “after” him for eight years, she just might purchase one of his paintings because of Trump.
“The thing about this,” she said, “is that Donald has now done something I thought he would never do. I like — I like the fact that George Bush — I like George Bush now, is what I’m trying to say. I’m having trouble saying it.”
Star Trek’s George Takei also weighed in: “You know things are bad when George W. Bush starts sounding like a member of the Resistance.”
You know things are bad when George W. Bush starts sounding like a member of the Resistance. https://t.co/OoGOjcVzfq
— George Takei (@GeorgeTakei) February 27, 2017
Most endearing, perhaps, was the open affection for Michelle Obama that Bush has displayed while promoting his book (“Portraits of Courage,” featuring his paintings of post-9/11 veterans).
The fondness took flight online last fall when, at the opening ceremony of the National Museum of African American History and Culture in D.C., cameras caught Obama and Bush in a brief but clearly warm embrace. The New York Times called it “the embrace seen round the world,” sharply symbolic at a time of political strife.
“That surprised everybody,” Bush said on the “Ellen DeGeneres Show” Thursday when the host asked about his “good friend” Michelle Obama.“That’s what is so weird about society today, that people on opposite sides of the political spectrum could actually like each other.”
In an interview with People magazine, Bush said: “When I saw her, it was a genuine expression of affection.”
Their friendship seemed to remind onlookers that even if they disagreed with Bush the president, there was no harm in feeling warm toward Bush the man.
Or perhaps it was affection by association, the feeling that anyone Michelle Obama seemed to like had to be okay.
According to Bush, it was shared laughs that bonded the two.
“She kind of likes my sense of humor,” Bush told People. “Anybody who likes my sense of humor, I immediately like.”
And now that the Obamas are entering their own presidential “afterlife,” George and Laura Bush have extended a bipartisan invitation for the two couples to join forces in supporting veterans.
“It’s going to take them a while to find their footing and figure out how they’re going to do what they want to do,” George Bush told People. “But if there’s a way to be symbiotic, we’ll do so.”
More from Morning Mix: