The man captured on video making xenophobic comments about Spanish-speaking employees at a New York deli has been identified as lawyer Aaron Schlossberg in a formal complaint filed with the state court disciplinary system.
Rep. Adriano Espaillat and Bronx Borough President Ruben Diaz Jr., both Democrats, filed the complaint in a letter on Thursday, saying that they believed the video depicted misconduct that should not be tolerated.
“What was witnessed in the vile video from Mr. Schlossberg, which has since gone viral, is humiliating and insulting attack on the more than 50 years of progress that this nation has made since the civil rights movement,” the two wrote. “The audacity to profile and verbally assault innocent bystanders and customers in a public commercial location is a violation of our civil society.”
Spurred on in part by a tweet from New York activist and writer Shaun King on Tuesday, the video has kicked off a cascade of emotion in the midst of an ongoing national debate about immigration and racially charged questions about what it means to be an American.
The footage shows a man, dressed in a white dress shirt and gray slacks, berating an employee at the fast-casual eatery Fresh Kitchen in midtown Manhattan because the staff was speaking Spanish.
“Your staff is speaking Spanish to customers when they should be speaking English,” he says. “Every person I listen to: He spoke it, he spoke it, she’s speaking it.”
The man then threatened to call immigration enforcement authorities on the employees, alleging, apparently with no evidence beyond the language that they were speaking, that they were not legal residents of the country.
“My guess is they’re not documented, so my next call is to ICE to have each one of them kicked out of my country,” he said. “If they have the balls to come here and live off my money — I pay for their welfare. I pay for their ability to be here. The least they can do — the least they can do — is speak English.”
The website for Schlossberg says he is a lawyer with a focus on commercial and insurance law and notes that he speaks Spanish and some French, Mandarin Chinese and Hebrew, in addition to English. His law office advertises that it can take phone calls in four foreign languages, an irony that was not lost on many commentators on social media.
Diaz said in an interview with The Washington Post that he thinks Schlossberg should be suspended or disbarred.
“This guy should know better. When you’re an attorney, you’re telling your clients what you should say and how you should conduct yourself,” he said. “Where in the Constitution or the law does it say that in a public place that you can’t use another language other than English? And then to add insult to injury he threatens to harass these people and that he will call ICE.”
Diaz did not specify what part of the New York State Court’s rules of professional conduct he believes Schlossberg to have violated.
Misconduct includes engaging “in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice,” stating or implying an ability “to influence improperly or upon irrelevant grounds any tribunal, legislative body or public official,” discriminating by hiring, promoting or determining other employment issues in the practice of law “on the basis of age, race, creed, color, national origin, sex, disability, marital status or sexual orientation,” and engaging “in any other conduct that adversely reflects on the lawyer’s fitness as a lawyer.”
Complaints are confidential unless a finding is made to sanction or reprimand the person, Lucian Chalfen, director of public information at the Unified Court System, said in an email statement.
Schlossberg did not respond to an immediate request for comment sent through his website.
Schlossberg has been the target of much anger since the rant was publicized. The Yelp listing for his law office was so flooded with thousands of one-star reviews — it had more than 2,900 as of Thursday afternoon — that the company announced it was conducting a “cleanup” of reviews motivated by news and not experiences with the business itself.
“Curious, how does a lawyer (years of studying and understanding Federal and State law) be openly racist? Especially in NY,” wrote one woman, identified as Sherry D. “That bias attitude doesn’t sit well and quite frankly, it’s hypocritical to promote on your website ‘Spanish, French and Chinese’ speaking.”
The listing of the law office on Google was also modified to make it appear that it was a “Spanish restaurant,” according to screenshots shared online before the listing was fixed.
Corporate Suites told The Post that it had terminated an agreement to provide meeting space, mail handling and telephone services to Schlossberg.
“Corporate Suites has a diverse and global community of business professionals working in a rich environment with mutual respect,” spokesman Hayim Alan Grant said in a statement. “We found Mr. Schlossberg’s statements offensive and contrary to our community norms.”
And an associate attorney who had been listed as one of the attorneys at Schlossberg’s firm appeared to have been removed from the website after the uproar.
The video kicked off a mad dash in New York as reporters from the city’s tabloid newspapers, the Daily News and New York Post, rushed to confront him about his statements. With cameras rolling, a couple of reporters pursued him down the street in the rain even as he began to run away, asking him pointed questions as he shielded himself under an umbrella. Another local reporter approached him at a courthouse in Queens. At some point, he was spotted in casual clothes sprinting away from an NBC News reporter.
In response to questions from The Washington Post, ICE declined to comment on the video but said that its tip line should be used to make “legitimate reports of suspected criminal activity” and not “as an instrument to intimidate or harass.”
According to the Center for Responsive Politics, Schlossberg gave $500 to Donald Trump in May 2016.
Critics and media outlets said they have identified Schlossberg in a handful of other videos of heated political moments in New York, including a protest against a Muslim activist last year where ralliers held signs and icons connected to a alt-right, the far-right movement associated with racism, sexism and anti-Semitism. The man is heard cursing at the person taking the video and chanting, “Milo,” for right-wing media personality Milo Yiannopoulos. Vice News unearthed footage of another episode where he yelled at protesters outside of Trump Tower in a “Make American great again,” hat. And YouTube vlogger Willie Morris drew attention to what he said was an apparently random encounter with Schlossberg in New York in 2016 where the man called him “ugly (foreigner)” on the street.
“I’m a citizen here; you’re not,” he said. “You’re not allowed to walk on the wrong side of the street.”
Amy B Wang contributed reporting.