The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Chicago has had more homicides this year than New York and Los Angeles combined

A woman sits on the curb as police investigate the scene where gunfire at a birthday party killed a man and injured a woman. (Ashlee Rezin/Chicago Sun-Times via AP)

The summer is winding down in Chicago, a city beset by violence that has skyrocketed to levels unseen in recent memory and is now rapidly approaching a grim milestone. A particularly deadly month has pushed Chicago’s number of homicides this year almost to the number seen in all of 2015, even as four months remain on the calendar.

August was a brutal month for Chicago, which has been dealing in tandem with staggering amounts of gun violence and an embattled police department tasked with fighting the bloodshed. There were 90 homicides in Chicago in August, a number that most major U.S. cities did not match during the entire first six months of 2016, according to police data.

Even as homicides have spiked in a number of cities, following increases in bloodshed in many of the same places last year, the situation in Chicago has stood out through sheer scale. The country’s third-biggest city has had more homicides this year than the only two bigger American cities — New York and Los Angeles — combined.

This year, 471 people have been killed in Chicago, about 50 percent ahead of the same point last year and almost even with the 473 total homicides recorded by police in 2015. The city, spurred by an August that was its most violent single month in almost two decades, is on pace to have more than 600 homicides in a single year for the first time since 2003.

America is safer than it was decades ago, but homicides are up again in a number of big cities

The story of Chicago’s bloodshed is one of gun violence. In August, when an average of three people were killed each day, there were 384 shooting incidents and 472 shooting victims, according to police department data. Police said more than 90 percent of the people killed this year were fatally shot, similar to the number from last year.

Authorities in Chicago say the violent crime there is largely being committed by repeat offenders with illegal guns, and police have targeted gang members who they say are known to law enforcement.

“The historical cycle of violence we have seen in some communities must come to an end,” Eddie Johnson, the Chicago police superintendent, said in a statement early Thursday. “Repeat gun offenders who drive the violence on our streets should not be there in the first place and it is time to changes the laws to ensure these violent offenders are held accountable for their crimes.”

Spiking homicide counts in big cities across the country

Chicago is one of multiple cities struggling with an increasing number of homicides this year, upticks that come after decades of falling crime nationwide. More than two dozen police agencies in major metropolitan areas reported spikes in homicides by the midway point of this year, and killings in Chicago and other places have received additional national attention after being invoked by Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump.

In some places, such as Chicago, the violence increased last year and has only continued to rise this year. But that is not uniformly true among cities where more people were killed last year than in 2014, according to police data.

Just after the midway point in August, there were 222 homicides in New York City, which was even with last year. Shootings have also declined there. Philadelphia had 190 killings through the end of August, up from the 174 a year earlier. Los Angeles had 182 homicides through the end of last week, down slightly from 186 a year before.

‘We have a problem.’ Homicides are up again this year in more than two dozen major U.S. cities.

Homicides went up in a number of cities nationwide last year, but some places bore a heavier toll than others in 2015. An analysis by the Brennan Center, a law and policy institute in New York, found that three cities — Chicago, Baltimore and Washington — accounted for more than half the overall increase in homicides last year in the country’s biggest cities.

Unlike in Chicago, violence has not escalated in the other two cities. In Baltimore, which had a record number of killings last year, there were 199 homicides by the end of last week, down from 218 at the same point a year earlier, according to police data. Washington recorded 162 homicides last year, the most since 2008. The nation’s capital had 90 homicides as of Thursday, down from 105 a year earlier.

Experts have warned against drawing broad conclusions from relatively limited data this year, noting that they do not necessarily suggest a trend. (The FBI has not yet released its national crime data, though it has released preliminary data for the first half of 2015 showing an increase in murders and violent crime.)

Crime rates across the country remain at historic lows, far below what the country saw a quarter-century ago, something criminologists point out when asked about the recent increases. Between 1990 and 1995, Chicago had at least 800 homicide victims each year. Los Angeles had 983 homicides in 1990, a number that ticked up in the early part of that decade; last year there were 283 killings. In Philadelphia, police say the 500 homicide victims in 1990 was its peak, while last year there were 280 homicide victims. New York had 2,262 murders in 1990, a number that fell to 352 last year, police say.

Chicago’s staggering rise in gun violence and killings

Still, the recent spikes in some cities — including places that, like Chicago, also saw upticks a year earlier — have prompted concern from law enforcement leaders unsure of what is causing them.

“People say to me, ‘Well, the increases are off of historic lows,’ ” FBI Director James Comey told reporters earlier this year during a discussion about the homicide numbers. “How does that make any of us feel any better? I mean, a whole lot more people are dying this year than last year, and last year than the year before, and I don’t know why for sure.”

This sentiment was echoed by Darrel Stephens, executive director of the Major Cities Chiefs Association, the group of law enforcement leaders that collected and released homicide data from dozens of cities.

“Even if we had decreases in every one of our cities, you still have too many people killed in America by homicide, more than any other industrialized nation in the world, and mostly because of gunfire, and mostly in high-poverty areas of our communities with a significant impact on African American populations,” Stephens said in an interview this summer. “Yes, we ought to be concerned about it.”

Law enforcement officials in cities across the country have suggested different reasons for the increases, pointing at times to gangs, a proliferation of guns, and drugs. Others, such as Comey, this year and last, have wondered whether police are acting less aggressively in an era of increased scrutiny (an idea known as the “Ferguson effect,” taking its name from the Missouri city where protests took place after a white police officer shot a black 18-year-old in 2014).

‘We have the fire of violence and gunfire’

In Chicago, police say they are working to fight the bloodshed, noting that murder arrests and gun arrests ticked up in August compared with the same month last year. The department also said it has seized or collected 5,900 illegal guns. But heading into the last third of the year, many people remain on edge. In a poll earlier this summer, people there said they thought kids growing up in Chicago were as likely to be the victims of violent crime as they were to graduate from college.

“We have parents begging their kids not to come home from college for Labor Day weekend” out of fear, the Rev. Michael Pfleger, who has marched against violence in the city, said during a protest Wednesday against gun violence, according to the Chicago Tribune.

Pfleger also called for the declaration of a state of emergency in response to the bloodshed. “When there are fires, we call a state of emergency,” he said. “When there are hurricanes, a state of emergency. When there’s floods, a state of emergency. Well, we have the fire of violence and gunfire. We have the floods of blood in our streets.”

Gov. Bruce Rauner (R) said Wednesday he would not do that or bring in the Illinois National Guard, saying that would be an “emotional” response that could possibly exacerbate the situation and “wouldn’t make sense.”

Chicago police to Donald Trump: ‘If you have a magic bullet to stop the violence,’ let us know

The problems in Chicago are not citywide, though. Police data shows that the killings are concentrated in areas across the city’s southern and western sides. Six of the city’s 25 police districts have seen killings remain flat or decline this year, while five districts on the south and west sides have been home to most of the homicide increases.

“Crime is a neighborhood phenomenon,” Richard Berk, a professor of statistics and criminology at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia, said this summer. “You have to look at particular neighborhoods, neighborhood by neighborhood, to see what’s going on.”

During his discussion of homicides nationwide earlier this year, the FBI director made a similar point, using Chicago as an example of a place where many may be removed from the bloodshed.

“I worry very much it’s a problem that most of America can drive around,” Comey said. He pointed to Chicago’s downtown shopping district as a place where “you can’t hear the sounds of gunshots that have killed” hundreds in other parts of the city.

“It’s happening in certain parts of the cities,” he said. “The people dying are almost entirely black and Latino men. We can’t drive around that problem.”

An embattled department tasked with fighting the violence

While this violence has persisted, Chicago police have also been the focus of a federal investigation as well as local efforts to reform the department. The Justice Department launched a sprawling probe into the Chicago police last year, not long after video footage was released showing a city police officer firing 16 rounds into Laquan McDonald, a black teenager. After the video was released, the police superintendent was dismissed, a mayoral task force pilloried the department as having “no regard” for the lives of black people and the city announced measures aimed at policing reform.

Watch: Here's what a database of complaints against Chicago police officers shows (Video: Gillian Brockell/The Washington Post)

The McDonald shooting continues to reverberate through the department, with no clear end in sight. This week, Johnson recommended firing five officers — including Jason Van Dyke, the officer who fatally shot McDonald in 2014 and has since been charged with murder — and accused them of lying about the incident. Through it all, the Justice Department’s probe continues, and such investigations often end with court-enforced orders demanding changes.

Chicago’s violence has again been pushed into national headlines by recently incidents, such as the death of Nykea Aldridge, cousin of Dwyane Wade, an NBA star and Chicago native. Aldridge was killed last month pushing a stroller on the sidewalk. Police said she was not the intended target but was instead shot by someone aiming for a different person.

Aldridge’s death received added attention after Trump pointed to the shooting and claimed it was evidence of “what I have been saying,” just days after the Republican nominee claimed that a “top police officer in Chicago” had told him there was a way to stop the bloodshed “within one week.”

Trump did not name the officer, and his campaign did not respond to a request to identify him. The Chicago police say no senior officials met with him or his campaign, but they added that he is welcome to offer his input.

“If you have a magic bullet to stop the violence anywhere, not just in Chicago but in America, then please, share it with us,” Johnson, the police superintendent, said this week. “We’d be glad to take that information and stop this violence.”

Further reading:

Chicago residents think kids growing up there are as likely to be violent-crime victims as college graduates

Donald Trump says a ‘top police officer’ in Chicago said he could stop the surging violence in a week

Police superintendent calls for firing officer who shot and killed Laquan McDonald

Chicago inspector general said multiple officers should be fired for lying in the McDonald case

Video of Paul O’Neal shooting shows Chicago officers firing at a fleeing car

Chicago will make some changes to its police department as a ‘down payment’ on reform