A body recently found floating near a Northern California cliff where a family’s SUV plunged 100 feet into the ocean has been identified as 12-year-old Ciera Hart, authorities said Tuesday.
Ciera, the youngest member of her family, was one of three children who remained missing after Jennifer Hart, 38, drove her wife and six adopted children off a scenic Pacific Ocean overlook last month, according to authorities, who believe the plunge was intentional. Preliminary toxicology results last week found that Jennifer Hart was drunk, with a blood alcohol level of 0.102. In California, drivers are considered legally drunk if they have a level of 0.08 or higher.
The vehicle was found upside down and partially submerged at the bottom of the cliff on March 26, and authorities so far have recovered the bodies of Jennifer Hart; her wife, Sarah Hart, also 38; and four of their six children: Markis, 19, Jeremiah, 14, Abigail, 14, and Ciera. (Authorities previously referred to her as Sierra.) Two children — Devonte, 15, and Hannah, 16 — remain missing and are feared dead.
Jennifer and Sarah Hart had been under investigation by police and child services officials in the three states where they lived — the most recent of which was Washington, where authorities opened a probe into the alleged neglect of the children just days before the crash. Toxicology tests show that, at the time of the crash, Sarah Hart and two of the children had a “significant amount” of an ingredient often found in the allergy drug Benadryl in their systems, authorities said.
Ciera’s autopsy and toxicology results are pending.
The California Highway Patrol revealed last week that the crash was not an accident.
Greg Baarts, acting assistant chief of the California Highway Patrol’s northern division, said preliminary data from the SUV’s air bag module suggested that the vehicle probably came to a stop at a gravel pullout roughly 70 feet from the cliff before it accelerated and “went straight off the edge.” Investigators also did not find any signs of an accident, such as tire or skid marks, or evidence suggesting that Jennifer Hart had lost control of the SUV.
Authorities believe the family departed from their home in Woodland, Wash. — leaving behind many of their belongings, including a pet and some chickens — and drove more than 500 miles south to California’s Mendocino County. The family was in Newport, Ore., about 160 miles southwest of their home, on the morning of March 24, and kept traveling south until they reached Fort Bragg in Mendocino County that evening, according to the California Highway Patrol.
The family’s 2003 GMC Yukon XL was found at the bottom of the cliff in nearby Westport two days later.
Days before the family left Washington, child services officials there had begun investigating the Harts for “alleged abuse or neglect.” The Washington State Department of Social and Health Services said it had tried to contact the Harts on March 23 after receiving a report of abuse but was unable to reach them. The agency tried a second time on March 26, the day the SUV was found, and again the next day.
Since the crash, a troubling narrative of alleged abuse has emerged, dating several years to when the family was living in Minnesota. Court documents there show that one of the couple’s daughters had come to school with bruises on her back and stomach. Sarah Hart told police that she lost her temper and bent the girl over a bathtub and spanked her. She was convicted of misdemeanor domestic assault and received a 90-day suspended jail sentence after the 2011 incident. But according to the Oregonian, the girl, Abigail, told police that Jennifer Hart was the one who had hit her.
The Harts later moved to a suburb in Portland, Ore. Child-welfare officials in that state also were alerted of potential abuse or neglect, the Oregonian reported, citing police records. But nothing came of the investigation. The family then moved across the Columbia River to a small town in Washington state. There, the couple’s neighbors recalled unusual encounters with the Hart children.
Bruce DeKalb said one of the sons, Devonte, came to his home several times in March to ask for food and said his parents weren’t feeding him. The teen also asked him and his wife to call Child Protective Services, DeKalb told The Washington Post. Devonte captured the world’s attention in 2014, when he was photographed sobbing in the arms of a white police officer in Portland, where people had gathered in support of civil rights protests in Ferguson, Mo.
A few months after the Harts moved next door in 2017, DeKalb said, one of the daughters, Hannah, pounded on his door at 1:30 a.m. She had jumped out of the family’s second-story window and run through the woods toward the neighbor’s house. The 16-year-old, who DeKalb thought was only 7 and was missing some front teeth, was “rattled to the bone.”
Officials said they have searched the family’s home, as well as the couple’s bank and credit card statements and phone records. They have yet to say whether they have found any clues of what might have led to the deaths. They said they have not found suicide notes.