But on Wednesday, White House Press Secretary Jay Carney said that he had spoken to someone in the meeting who contradicted Durbin's account of what "one GOP House Leader" said to Obama.
"It did not happen," Carney told reporters at his daily briefing.
Durbin's office, in turn, says the White House is wrong.
“Senator Durbin stands by his comments,” Max Gleischman told the Washington Post.
The White House statement drew a strong reaction from House Republicans, who believed Durbin invented the comment to cast them as personally spiteful.
Brendan Buck, a spokesman for House Speaker John A. Boehner (R-Ohio), said in a statement that “Senator Durbin’s accusation is a serious one, and it appears to have been invented out of thin air."
"The senator should disclose who told him this account of events, retract his reckless allegation immediately and apologize," Buck said.
The back-and-forth presents an awkward situation for Obama and Durbin, who at one time represented Illinois together in the Senate. It also comes at a time, after the divisive government shutdown, when Obama is seeking to cool partisan passions and move ahead with his broader legislative agenda.
Ed O'Keefe contributed to this report. Originally posted at 3:12 p.m.