While Clinton was not in New York on Sept. 11, she flew there on Sept. 12, in one of the few airplanes allowed to travel after the attacks. Pictures of Giuliani and Clinton inspecting the destruction together are widely available.
Giuliani, warming up a crowd before Trump took the stage, also attacked Clinton over comments she appears to have made during a paid speech to the Global Business Travelers Association, the transcript of which was revealed in a batch of campaign staff emails distributed by WikiLeaks.
Giuliani said that Clinton told the group that terrorism is not a threat. That misrepresents her comments. According to the WikiLeaks documents, Clinton said in the speech that terrorism is “not a threat to us as a nation, it is not going to endanger our economy or our society, but it is a real threat. It is a danger to our citizens here at home.” The Clinton campaign has refused to authenticate the emails or the transcripts.
“Don’t tell me you belong to our very, very tight group of never forget. Don’t tell me that, if for money you go tell people that terrorism is not a threat to our nation,” Giuliani said.
Clinton, who was a U.S. senator from New York at the time of 9/11, was in the District that day. The Pentagon was also attacked, and security officials feared the Capitol could also be targeted. Clinton flew to New York with fellow Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.) soon after the attacks.
She describes that scene in detail in her book, “Hard Choices,” and refers to the “long sleepless night in Washington” before flying to New York on Sept. 12. She does not appear to have said publicly at any point that she was in New York City on Sept. 11, 2001.
She most recently described her experience in the aftermath of 9/11 during an interview with CNN last month in which she detailed finding out about the attack that day as she was en route to the Capitol.
“There weren’t that many survivors; the ones that did survive were grievously injured. The loss of life was overwhelming,” Clinton told CNN during the interview. “But it was also my job and the job of other officials to get our city and state and country what we needed.”
Earlier this year, Trump praised Clinton’s efforts after the attacks, saying in July she was “enormously supportive and enormously helpful.”
Giuliani has become a regular presence on the campaign trail and is an active TV surrogate for Trump. He said Wednesday that Americans “need a strong man, need an independent man, need a man who tells it straight.
“Sometimes really straight,” he added, laughing. “But boy, a heckofa lot better than being a liar.”