The Trump administration is threatening to withhold highway funding from California if it doesn't clean up its air quality. But California leaders are firing back, hard — and accusing the federal government of actually preventing it from cleaning up its pollution.
“We won’t be intimidated by this brazen political stunt,” California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) said in a defiant statement after the Environmental Protection Agency threat.
California leaders are angry that the Trump administration took away California's authority to curb greenhouse gas emissions from vehicles last week — which they have repeatedly argued would also help it clean up lung-choking smog in the state.
“We won’t go back to the days when our air was the color of mud,” Newsom said. “We won’t relive entire summers when spending time outside amounted to a public health risk.”
EPA Administrator Andrew Wheeler's letter was made public as California leaders were mounting an offensive against President Trump for his loss of leadership on climate change at this week's United Nations climate summit. They seized on the high-profile forum to show they were the true leaders on environmental issues.
“I don’t know what the hell happened to this country that we have a president that we do today on this issue,” Newsom (D) said to applause in New York, according to the Los Angeles Times. “Because it’s a damn shame. It really is. I’m not a little embarrassed about it — I’m absolutely humiliated by what’s going on.”
Newsom was also quick to insist the threat against his left-leaning state was based in pure politics. Wheeler's letter to the California Air Resources Board said the state “has failed to carry out its most basic tasks under the Clean Air Act” and could risk losing federal money, as Juliet Eilperin and I reported Tuesday, the state is not alone in its struggles.
It's true that some 40 counties in California do not meet federal air quality standards. California’s mountain ranges form cauldron-like basins in which smog brews. And the high-sky number of people who live in the state, along with the many cars they drive, don’t help.
But about three dozen other states not targeted with EPA letters also have counties that did not meet standards for six pollutants as of the end of August. And the California Air Resources Board said the federal government isn’t helping it fight pollution from one of its biggest sources there: cars.
“This letter appeared only days after EPA attacked our state authority on cars, increasing air pollution while at the same time limiting our ability to reduce it,” CARB Executive Officer Richard Corey said in a statement responding to Wheeler’s letter.
Speaking in New York on Tuesday following the U.N. climate summit, Newsom suggested that California is doing more than most states to curb pollution. “We're not asserting a paradigm, we're proving it,” he said of creating jobs in green industries. “That paradigm is now challenged by an EPA that’s been weaponized by the Trump administration.”
Newsom’s predecessor as governor, Jerry Brown, attended the climate summit, too, using it to launch an initiative with a geopolitical rival, China, which is now quarreling with the Trump administration over trade.
The California-China Climate Institute, based at Beijing’s Tsinghua University and the University of California at Berkeley, will tackle climate problems both technological and political. Brown founded it with China’s most senior and veteran climate policy official, Xie Zhenhua. The Chinese province of Guangzhou will also participate.
Brown acknowledged in an interview with The Post last week he was forming the partnership at a time of deep distrust of China amid the trade war. But he said it made sense “because of California’s unique role in enforcing clean air laws, we’ve developed expertise, engineers, lawyers, technicians.”
The partnership is especially striking given Trump's ongoing feuds with California on tackling pollution.
Trump “comes along, denies climate change and wants to stop the state that’s doing the most about it,” he said. “It makes no sense. I have to say that borders on the criminal.”
Carol Morello and Steven Mufson contributed reporting.
Read more here:
— The latest sobering climate report: Climate change is already having a major impact on the world’s oceans and frozen regions, according to a new report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. And the report, compiled with the help of 100 scientists from around the world, warned that if global warming is left unchecked, the impacts thus far are only a sign of catastrophic consequences still to come, The Post’s Chris Mooney and Brady Dennis report.
Given current emissions levels, a number of serious impacts are essentially unavoidable:
- Rising greenhouse gas emissions have already fueled monster storms, deadly heat waves, record sea ice loss and harm to coral reefs.
- By 2050, extreme floods that usually hit coastal cities and small island nations every 100 years will become a yearly occurrence.
- By the end of the century, the world could see a total sea level rise of 3.6 feet. That’s higher than the IPCC estimate in 2013, when the group said the rise would be just over three feet.
- By the year 2100, marine heat waves – blamed for killing corals and other critical ocean organisms – could become 20 times more common in a best-case scenario and 50 times more common in the worst case.
— “A very happy young girl” strikes back: Climate activist Greta Thunberg had a sharp response to Trump’s seemingly sarcastic description of the 16-year-old climate activist. Trump tweeted a news story about Thunberg’s impassioned remarks to United Nations leaders, saying: “She seems like a very happy young girl looking forward to a bright and wonderful future. So nice to see!” Later, Thunberg adjusted her profile to say just that: “A very happy young girl looking forward to a bright and wonderful future.”
— Senate confirms nominee for Interior Dept. lawyer who is under investigation: Senators voted 51 to 43 to confirm Daniel Jorjani to be the Interior Department’s top lawyer despite an outcry from Democrats who say he has lied to lawmakers.
- The probe: The Interior Department’s internal watchdog is currently looking into Jorjani’s role in creating the agency’s new Freedom of Information Act policy that enables political appointees to review requests.
- What Democrats said: Before the vote, Senate Minority Leader Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.) pointed to previous Interior Department officials, including former secretary Ryan Zinke, who have been the focus of ethical investigations. “It’s obvious that the Interior Department sorely needs transparency." And Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), who called on the agency’s watchdog to expand its investigation of the FOIA policy to include Jorjani, urged Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) not to “ignore the serous allegations facing this nominee.”
— Some corporations step up on climate: A number of corporations made commitments to curb their contribution to climate change this week even as commitments from world leaders stalled at the United Nations summit. More than 20 multinationals pledged to get 100 percent of their electricity from renewables, The Post’s Steven Mufson reports, “bringing to 300 the number of renewable commitments from companies with $5.5 trillion in revenue, according to the Climate Group.” Other companies pledged to electrify their vehicle fleets, 10 companies committed to accelerating energy efficiency by 3 percent a year and another company said it would more than double its renewable energy purchases to more than 1.5 gigawatts of wind and solar.
— Court rejects government effort to stop lawsuit against wildlife council: A federal-district court blocked an effort by the Trump administration to dismiss a lawsuit against an Interior Department wildlife protection council that critics argue is stacked with “trophy hunters.” The International Wildlife Conservation Council was announced by then-Secretary Ryan Zinke in November 2017 and its members included a “a National Rifle Association official, six members who are listed as active hunters and five members who are said to represent wildlife conservation groups,” The Post’s Erin B. Logan has reported.
— Court pauses huge logging push in Alaskan rainforest: A federal court halted a major logging operation in Alaska’s Tongass National Forest, the largest such operation on U.S. Forest Service-run land in about three decades, Courthouse News reports. The preliminary injunction stops the agency from pushing ahead with its 15-year plan to log 40,000 acres of the forest. In the ruling, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason said the environmental impact statement “does not fully explain to the public how or where actual timber activities will affect localized habitats.”
- The Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee holds hearings to examine fishery failures and improving disaster declaration and relief process.
- The House Agriculture Subcommittee on Conservation and Forestry holds a hearing on the National Forest System on Thursday.
- The House Science, Space and Technology Committee holds a hearing on forecasting and communicating extreme weather in a changing climate on Thursday.
— Get ready for some hiberation:
If you've wondered what the brackets will be like for the 2019 Fat Bear Week, wonder no more; here they are! Make sure to waddle over to Facebook to cast your votes daily, from Oct 2nd through Oct 8th.#FatBearWeek #FindYourPark pic.twitter.com/AyCfUAh2O3— Katmai National Park (@KatmaiNPS) September 24, 2019