The country’s health-care industry heavyweights — including insurers, pharmacy middlemen, doctors and branded and generic drugmakers — have become simultaneous allies and enemies.
That's because of two big ideas that have captured the attention of lawmakers and policymakers this year: combating the high cost of prescription drugs and achieving universal coverage through expanding Medicare.
The first effort, undertaken by both Congress and the Trump administration, has pitted industry players against one another, as each participant in the drug supply pipeline tries to shift blame onto everyone else for why prescription medications are more expensive in the United States than anywhere else.
But the second effort has actually brought a wide swath of the industry together -- to combat what it views as the growing threat of Medicare-for-all plans pushed by some Democrats.
Those involved in the industry coalition (which I wrote about here) insist they’ve found it relatively easy to unite in opposition to a single idea — Medicare-for-all and other iterations of it — even as they’re fiercely battling on many other fronts.
“I think people assume it is a tense conversation, but we are united,” said Lauren Crawford Shaver, executive director of the Partnership for America’s Health Care Future. “The other stuff that is happening out there doesn’t come up in our conversations.”
The partnership — formed over the summer by the leading associations for insurers, doctors and drugmakers and now comprised of more than two dozen groups — has been running ads exhorting Democrats to reject Medicare-for-all ideas and arguing that such a system would hurt access to vital health-care services. Yesterday, the group launched a six-figure ad buy targeting Democrats from Iowa and Pennsylvania.
David Merritt, executive vice president of public affairs at insurers association America’s Health Insurance Plans, told me members of the group avoid discussing other policy issues that could divide them.
“We try and keep focused on the issue that has brought us together, so there’s no real debate or discussion about any of those other issues,” Merritt said.
Crawford Shaver gave a similar answer. “This group is here to discuss strengthening our current health-care system and thinking through the challenges of Medicare-for-all-style proposals, including buy-in, hard stop,” she told me. “We’re not taking on every issue in health-care because that would not work.”
That’s crystal clear when it comes to drug costs. While the skyrocketing prices of prescription drugs is a top concern among voters and members of Congress from both parties, the increased attention has only augmented the blame games constantly played by pharmaceutical makers on one side and the insurers and pharmacy benefit managers who negotiate for them on the other side.
Just look at the slew of regulations the Department of Health and Human Services says it's trying to move forward – potential new rules the agency has proposed over the past six months aimed at bringing more transparency to drug prices and reducing what the government pays for pharmaceuticals through the Medicare program.
—The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America has voiced deep disapproval of a new international index proposed by HHS that would reduce payments for Medicare drugs dispensed directly by doctors. The drugmakers association is also up in arms over separate proposals to require them to list drug prices in television ads (this rule could be released any day now) and to allow insurers to restrict coverage for certain classes of drugs considered crucial for seniors living with serious and complex health conditions.
— America’s Health Insurance Plans – while applauding those crack downs on the pharmaceutical industry – have its own beef with the administration, which in January released a regulation that, if finalized, would essentially ban drug makers from paying big rebates to Medicare plans. These rebates are seen as one reason list prices are being pushed ever higher. The drug industry, on the other hand, thinks this is a great idea.
Merritt told me the industry's partnership against Medicare-for-all has made him more hopeful they could work together on other issues as well. But that would require each player along the drug supply pipeline to assume some element of responsibility. When I pressed Merritt on the proposed ban on drug rebates, for example, he quickly responded with AHIP's arguments against it -- that it distracts from the real problem of drug makers setting high list prices to begin with.
“Everyone is ducking and scrambling and trying to point the finger at someone else,” as one GOP lobbyist told me. “Everybody is trying to cover their butt and it’s hard to unravel that system and create a new one.”
|You are reading The Health 202, our must-read newsletter on health policy.|
|Not a regular subscriber?|
AHH: Health officials from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the World Health Organization are dialing back travel warnings for pregnant women now that the Zika epidemic that was causing thousands of birth defects has mostly petered out.
In 2016, WHO had designated the virus as a global health emergency, and health officials in the United States had advised pregnant women or women who may become pregnant to stay away from nearly 100 countries or regions. But last month, that warning was downgraded by the CDC, and our Post colleague Lena H. Sun reports WHO is planning to follow with a similar easing of travel warnings.
“Officials said the disease has died down in most of the world — although they think it is still circulating at a much lower level,” Lena writes. She adds Zika is “still circulating in Southeast Asia and South Asia, but large numbers of new infections and Zika-related birth defects are not being reported … The only region reporting an active Zika outbreak is in India’s northwestern state of Rajasthan.”
Still, health officials say pregnant women or those who are thinking about getting pregnant should talk to their health-care providers about Zika risks before traveling. But there’s not always a clear way to get the best information.
“Academic researchers and CDC officials say Zika has waned in most places in the Western Hemisphere because so many people became infected,” Lena adds. “After being infected, people are immune to the virus and cannot pass it to other people either directly, via sex and bodily fluids, or through mosquitoes.”
OOF: When doctors at a Pennsylvania pediatric practice were targeted online by anti-vaccine activists for a video reminding parents to get their kids vaccinated for human papillomavirus, the doctors helped turned that online attack into the first systematic research into how anti-vax activists coordinate harmful social media campaigns.
New findings out this morning, based on data the practice shared with researchers at the University of Pittsburgh Center for Research on Media, Technology, “confirm previous research about those who are opposed or reluctant to vaccinate and the key arguments that resonate with them,” Lena reports.
The attacks came from members of private anti-vaccine Facebook groups. The majority of the commenters were mothers. The report also found 56 percent of the commenter sample supports President Trump, while 11 percent expressed support for Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.). Many are vaccine-hesitant or opposed to vaccines.
After posting a video on the practice’s Facebook page, doctors had received a barrage of 10,000 negative comments from about 800 commenters across the country and around the world, threatening the doctors or telling them they had been brainwashed. The new study was based on a random sample of 200 of the commenters and analysis of publicly available information on their Facebook pages over two years.
“Among the anti-vaccine themes in the comments were a mistrust of the scientific community, concerns about personal liberty, perceived risks about vaccine safety and the belief that government and pharmaceutical companies are part of a conspiracy to hide information,” Lena writes.
OUCH: State and national organizations have filed a lawsuit against the Trump administration to attempt to stop New Hampshire from implementing work requirements for Medicaid beneficiaries.
The groups cite concerns that eligible individuals will end up losing coverage.
The groups filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia asserting that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services violated the Medicaid Act when it approved New Hampshire’s plan to mandate that beneficiaries work 100 hours a month to maintain coverage, as the Concord Monitor’s Ethan DeWitt reports.
The lawsuit in New Hampshire follows two others in Kentucky and Arkansas that have sought to challenge Medicaid work requirements.
— New CDC analysis found the synthetic and potent opioid fentanyl has led to increased rates of fatal drug overdoses across the country, with the sharpest spike among African Americans.
There was on average a 141 percent increase in fentanyl-related drug overdoses among African Americans each year from 2011 to 2016, according to the data, our Post colleague Joel Achenbach reports. For Hispanics there was an increased rate of 118 percent every year on average during that time and a 61 percent on average increase for non-Hispanic whites.
The report is the first from the CDC that particularly isolates the role of fentanyl in the broad opioid epidemic.
“The report provides a reminder that deadly opioids are increasingly taking the lives of urban drug users,” Joel writes. “The new report shows that this is an epidemic overwhelmingly east of the Mississippi River, and particularly acute in New England, where street heroin historically has been like fentanyl sold in powder form, such that the two drugs are easily blended.”
— White House officials and several members of Congress earlier this month attended a “Make Families Great Again” conference at the Hungarian Embassy.
Valerie Huber, a senior HHS adviser known for support of abstinence-only education, delivered the keynote address at the event, which promoted a seven-point “Family Protection Action Plan” from Prime Minister Viktor Orban that’s meant to promote marriage and families, as our colleague Ariana Eunjung Cha reports.
“The increasingly close relations between the United States and Hungary have drawn concern from civil society and advocacy groups,” she writes. “Hungary’s birth policies made headlines recently after the government announced its seven-point plan to entice Hungarian women to have more children, with offers that include waiving income taxes for life for those who have four or more babies and subsidies to buy larger cars for their larger families.”
The Trump administration’s support for Hungary also represents a shift from the Obama administration, which essentially shunned the nation “to signal U.S. opposition to Orban’s restrictions on free speech, his anti-immigration policies and his efforts to weaken the nation’s constitutional protections.”
— Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar and FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb penned an op-ed in The Post calling on the e-cigarette industry to address what they call an “epidemic” of teen vaping.
“We agree with those who believe that e-cigarettes may offer a lower-risk alternative for adult smokers who still want access to nicotine,” they write. “But the continued availability of this opportunity to adults is being endangered by the e-cigarette industry’s slowness to address the dangers its products pose to teens.”
The pair panned proponents of the products who, they say, dismiss the growth of use among youths. They said the Trump administration has worked to bolster efforts to tame that increase. They said the FDA is planning to expand a public education campaign this summer to reach at-risk teens.
The pair also stressed the agency’s focus on the issue will remain despite the departure of Gottlieb, who has made it a priority to address youth e-cigarette use. Gottlieb announced his resignation earlier this month.
“The country is at a crossroads when it comes to these products,” they write. “Absent a reversal in the trends of youth e-cigarette use, we envision a world where the FDA will continue to narrow the off-ramp for adults seeking a less harmful alternative to combustible cigarettes, in order to close the on-ramp that has resulted in the widespread and increasingly frequent use of e-cigarettes by teens.”
— In a radio interview this week, Kentucky’s Republican Gov. Matt Bevin said he purposefully exposed all nine of his kids to chickenpox and said he didn’t support the state’s mandatory chickenpox vaccine.
“We found a neighbor that had it,” the first-term governor said during an interview on Talk 104.1. “And I went and made sure every one of my kids was exposed to it and they got it. And they had it as children, they were miserable for a few days, and they all turned out fine.”
He added: “This is America and the federal government should not be forcing this upon people.”
“Chickenpox is less deadly in children than adults, but public health experts say it is still important to get vaccinated to prevent a small number of deaths every year and protect others with weaker immune systems,” as our Post colleague Eli Rosenberg reports, adding health experts warned that Bevin seemed misinformed.
“It’s a public health hazard,” said Steven Teutsch, a former CDC officer and an adjunct professor of health policy and management at the University of California at Los Angeles. “One of the things that we worry about is that you know people who think these things — you’re on a slippery slope that leaves the kids and the population vulnerable.”
— And here are a few more good reads:
- The 2019 National HIV Prevention Conference in Atlanta, Ga. continues.
- The CATO institute holds an event on harm reduction.
- The Bipartisan Policy Center holds an event on overcoming health care challenges in immigrant communities.
- The Brookings Institution holds an event on emerging policy solutions to surprise medical bills on Friday.
Trump continued his barrage of attacks on the late senator John McCain (R-Ariz.), saying he "didn’t get a thank you,," for approving McCain’s funeral: