There’s a growing body of evidence that the Affordable Care Act has saved lives and made some Americans healthier since the sweeping health-care bill was passed nearly a decade ago.
This evidence largely comes from states that expanded Medicaid under the ACA, my Washington Post colleague Amy Goldstein reports. In some areas, such as parts of Detroit where poverty and illness are common, previously uninsured patients now have coverage under the expanded safety-net program. For some people, that means not only getting primary care -- but having thousands of dollars for medication and medical bills now paid for. In other areas, more prescriptions are getting filled and dialysis patients are living longer in places where coverage was expanded.
But many backers of the health-care law have not yet seized on this good news to galvanize public support, even as the fate of the ACA remains in question. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit is expected to rule any day now on the high-stakes case, after a federal judge in Texas ruled late last year that the entire law is unconstitutional. No matter the outcome, the decision is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court.
ACA supporters “have not taken political advantage of the signs that the ACA is translating into better health — at least, not yet,” Amy writes.
Instead, Democrats have centered their rallying cries on the effort from President Trump and the GOP to undermine the health-care law, attacking Republicans over the lawsuit filed by more than a dozen GOP-led states that seeks to overturn the ACA. Democrats have also pointed to the administration's push for skimpy, inexpensive health plans that eschew ACA requirements. Meanwhile, others in the party, including a number of 2020 Democratic presidential candidates, have called for even more sweeping changes to the nation’s health-care system, proposing Medicare-for-all.
It’s hard to conclusively say what difference the ACA has made in people’s lives, but research points to how the law has helped. “Compared with similar people who have stable coverage through their jobs, previously uninsured people who bought ACA health plans with federal subsidies had a big jump in detection of high blood pressure and in the number of prescriptions they had filled, according to a 2018 study in the journal Health Affairs," Amy writes.
“And after the law allowed young adults to stay longer on their parents’ insurance policies, fewer 19- to 25-year-olds with asthma failed to see a doctor because it cost too much, according to an analysis of survey results published earlier this year by researchers at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.”
Here are some other findings that show how the ACA has made some people healthier:
- A 2017 study found that in Michigan, where expanded Medicaid covers about 650,000 people, patients who had cardiac bypasses or valve operations had fewer complications compared with similar patients in Virginia, which had not yet expanded Medicaid.
- A 2018 study found infant deaths, especially among black infants, decreased more sharply in areas with expanded Medicaid (although the study does not indicate which families had coverage through ACA expansions).
- More than 25,000 Ohio smokers got help that led them to quit through the state's Medicaid expansion.
- A National Bureau of Economic Research paper from July that examined “deaths from all causes among adults from their mid-50s to mid-60s, found that dying in a given year has been significantly less common in the states that expanded Medicaid.” Amy adds: "The paper said that perhaps 15,600 deaths could have been avoided if the expansion had been nationwide, but it cautioned that is a rough estimate in part because the study was unable to look specifically at the people who signed up for Medicaid."
From the Senate Democrats' campaign arm:
“President Trump has dismantled as much of the law as his administration can.” So what are Senate Republicans doing about it? Nothing — and they continue to refuse to stand up to their party’s dangerous health care lawsuit. https://t.co/zKLKO6wnp0— Senate Democrats (@dscc) October 1, 2019
From Rep. Carolyn B. Maloney (D-N.Y.):
Yet some Democrats have pointed to the law's success as a reason to protect the ACA or to expand its reach, rather than overhaul the system:
From Sen. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.):
We have two paths as a party.— Michael Bennet (@MichaelBennet) September 27, 2019
We can be on offense on health care, or we can be on defense.
When we’re protecting and building on the Affordable Care Act, we win. That’s the path we should choose—not taking away health care with Medicare for All. pic.twitter.com/J3nRI9OO5F
Rep. Ami Bera (D-Calif.):
The #AffordableCareAct is saving lives and making people healthier, despite the Trump Administration's ongoing attempts to dismantle it.— Ami Bera, M.D. (@RepBera) September 30, 2019
I'll continue to fight to protect and strengthen the law. #ProtectOurCare
Rep. Betty McCollum (D-Minn.):
Despite ongoing attacks from Republicans in Congress & the Trump administration, the Affordable Care Act is working. Not only are millions more covered, but many people are healthier & are living longer. I'll keep fighting to #ProtectOurCare. https://t.co/LY96WTmaww— Rep. Betty McCollum (@BettyMcCollum04) September 30, 2019
Patient advocate Peter Morley:
I've testified to this twice this year:— Peter Morley (@morethanmySLE) September 30, 2019
The Affordable Care Act has saved millions of lives and has given Millions access to insurance. The uninsured rate has plummeted! We must #ProtectPEC for 130M. https://t.co/RLPA6p6qv9
Civil rights attorney Sasha Samberg-Champion:
For all the fulminating over the individual mandate, it turns out the Medicaid expansion of the Affordable Care Act was the lasting public policy success. And it would be even greater if SCOTUS hadn't permitted states to opt out. https://t.co/vVqrxXH0vm— Sasha Samberg-Champion (@ssamcham) September 30, 2019
To be sure, ACA plans remain too costly for some Americans, especially for individuals who don't qualify for federal subsidies. That's something lawmakers have tried to address: It's why Democrats have looked for ways to make ACA plans more affordable and why the Trump administration and some Republicans have pushed for alternative insurance plans that skirt ACA rules and protections.
Meanwhile, a recent survey from the Kaiser Family Foundation found support among Democrats for the ACA is at an all-time high. It found that 84 percent of Democrats had favorable views of the law, the largest share for Democrats since KFF began tracking ACA favorabilty.
The survey also found 55 percent of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents want to see a 2020 presidential candidate who wants to build on the law, expand coverage and lower costs, compared with 40 percent who said they would prefer replacing the ACA with a national Medicare-for-all system.
Read Amy's full report here:
AHH: Almost 80 percent of rural America is designated as “medically underserved” by the federal government. Doctors are increasingly hard to fine. Rural areas are home to 20 percent of the nation’s populations but just 10 percent of its doctors — and that rate is worsening ever year, our Post colleague Eli Saslow reports in this deep dive.
“In Texas alone, 159 of the state’s 254 counties have no general surgeons, 121 counties have no medical specialists, and 35 counties have no doctors at all,” he writes. “Thirty more counties are each forced to rely on just a single doctor.”
Ed Garner is a 68-year-old physician in Texas who serves, along with nurses and physician assistants at Culberson Hospital, an area of 11,000 square miles.
"Thirty more counties are each forced to rely on just a single doctor, like Garner, a family physician by training who by necessity has become so much else: medical director of Culberson County. Head physician for a nearby immigration detention center. Director of a rural health clinic. Chief of staff for Culberson Hospital. And medical director for the hospital’s emergency room, where the latest patient was being wheeled in as Garner introduced himself," Eli writes.
OOF: Rep. Chris Collins (R-N.Y.), the president’s first congressional supporter, is resigning from Congress and is set to plead guilty to charges of insider trading following allegations that he schemed with his son to avoid losses on an investment in a biotechnology company, Innate Immunotherapeutics.
Collins, who was on the board of the Australian company, allegedly tipped his son off to information that was used by numerous people to avoid more than $700,000 in losses.
“Collins sent a two-sentence resignation letter to New York Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo (D) on Monday," my Post colleagues Renae Merle and Mike DeBonis report. "... He sent a similar letter to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.). The resignation will become effective after a letter is officially filed at a scheduled House session Tuesday."
Renae and Mike write: “Collins won reelection last year after initially suspending his campaign, then reversing that decision despite pressure from Republicans to step aside and allow another GOP candidate on the ballot. Collins was sworn in for a fourth term in January but was not seated on any House committees pending resolution of his indictment.”
OUCH: Drugstores, including the nation’s largest pharmacy chain, CVS, have pulled Zantac and generic versions of the heartburn drug from their shelves after concerns about a possible cancer risk. The products have small levels of nitrosodimethylamine, a probable carcinogen linked to liver damage, my Post colleagues Kim Bellware and Carolyn Y. Johnson report.
Meanwhile, the Food and Drug Administration is investigating the possible patient risk.
“The decision by the pharmacy giant adds to a flurry of worldwide concern about the drug,” they write. “Major manufacturers of the generic form, ranitidine, have announced recalls, and other countries have requested that companies halt distribution of the drug or issued recalls.”
The FDA has stopped short of asking the public to stop taking ranitidine that remains on the market.
“The agency is working with international regulators and industry partners to determine the source of this impurity in ranitidine. We are also working to understand what happens to NDMA levels in the body after administration of ranitidine,” FDA spokesman Jeremy Kahn said. “The FDA will take appropriate measures based on the results of the ongoing investigation.”
And Sanofi, the drug company that manufactures Zantac, has not recalled the product. “The FDA reported that the levels of N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA) in ranitidine in preliminary tests barely exceed amounts found in common foods,” Sanofi spokeswoman Ashleigh Koss told our colleagues. “We are working closely with the FDA and are conducting our own robust investigations to ensure we continue to meet the highest quality safety and quality standards.”
— Nearly all teenagers in Maryland will be prohibited from buying tobacco and e-cigarettes starting today thanks to a new law raising the buying age for tobacco to 21.
The new law takes effect as state and federal leaders nationwide have sought to crack down on vaping products amid an outbreak of vaping-related illnesses that have sickened more than 800 people and have been linked to 12 deaths.
“The chief architect of the statute, House Economic Matters Committee Chairman Dereck E. Davis (D-Prince George’s), plans to introduce legislation in January to completely ban flavored vaping products, which public health officials contend make e-cigarettes more appealing to young people,” my Post colleague Erin Cox reports.
— Meanwhile, state health officials in Wisconsin and Illinois revealed the strongest clues into what may be behind the mysterious illnesses: The majority of sickened patients reported using illicit vape cartridges containing THC, the psychoactive component of marijuana.
The state officials said they interviewed 86 patients who used a range of e-cigarette products and that the majority used THC products “sold as prefilled vape cartridges — tiny disposable containers — and obtained from informal sources, officials said,” my Post colleagues Lena H. Sun and Laurie McGinley report.
Several states have rushed to call for bans or limits on vaping products amid the growing alarm about the illnesses: Washington state Gov. Jay Inslee (D) has called for an emergency ban on flavored vaping products that contain nicotine or marijuana. Rhode Island Gov. Gina Raimondo (D) has signed an executive order banning the sale of flavored e-cigarettes. Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker (R) announced a four-month ban on all vaping products. Michigan and New York also are banning flavored e-cigarette products.
— And here are a few more good reads from The Post and beyond:
- The CATO Institute holds an event on naloxone policy an training on Wednesday.
- The Center for Strategic and International Studies hosts an event on the outcomes of the UN high-level meeting on health coverage on Thursday.
- The CATO Institute holds an event on patients, privacy and prescription drug monitoring programs on Thursday.
How California lawmakers are trying to allow college athletes to get paid: