The USS Abner Read had finished one leg of its anti-submarine patrol and was turning to start the next. Off the shore of Kiska, in Alaska’s Aleutian chain, the sea was calm, and the moon could be glimpsed behind clouds and mist.
It had struck a mine, which snapped off a large section of the stern, sending the piece and its five-inch gun to the bottom with as many as 70 men trapped inside.
On Wednesday, maritime scientists announced that they had found the sunken stern and its big gun, encrusted with sea growth, in 290 feet of water amid one of World War II’s most untouched battlefields.
No remains of sailors were seen or recovered.
The bulk of the Abner Read remained afloat that night. It was later repaired and sent back to the battle. In 1944, the ship was hit again, this time by a Japanese suicide plane, and sank off the Philippine island of Samar.
“It was a bad-luck ship,” said a 94-year-old sailor who survived both attacks. “But I came through it, so I was lucky. A lot of people didn’t. ”
The story of the Abner Read, which was named for a Civil War Navy hero, begins at Kiska, where it had been dispatched after its commissioning in 1943.
And there, 75 years later, on July 17, underwater archaeologists found the 75-foot section of the stern, where scores of men probably remain entombed.
The expedition was funded by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and was run by Project Recover, a partnership of the University of Delaware, the Scripps Institution of Oceanography at the University of California San Diego, and the BentProp Project.
Its aim was to study the almost untouched underwater battlefield of the World War II fight between the United States and Japan for the Aleutian Islands.
The Japanese seized Kiska in June 1942 and weren’t driven off until July 1943, after relentless shelling and bombing by U.S. forces.
Along with the Abner Read’s stern, a dozen Japanese ships, two Japanese submarines and numerous downed American airplanes are believed to be in the local waters, according to Mark Moline of the University of Delaware.
And that, in part, was what drew Project Recover, which focuses mostly on locating World War II aircraft lost at sea, said Andrew Pietruszka of the Scripps Institution, Project Recover’s lead archaeologist.
The project’s attention was first drawn to a downed B-24 bomber near Kiska, but it expanded after the team learned about the Abner Read, he said in a telephone interview Tuesday.
“I knew almost nothing about Kiska and the Aleutian campaign, so it caught my attention,” he said. “There’s got to be shipwrecks, and there’s got to be submarines. [This is] such an unknown part of the war, and in such a remote area.”
“We wanted to tell that story,” he said.
The project got a $600,000 grant from NOAA and spent two weeks with a research vessel at Kiska in July.
‘Everything was peaceful’
Seaman first class Daryl Weathers, 19, a doctor’s son from Los Angeles, was in the radar room on the bridge, standing the midwatch — midnight to 4 a.m.
“Everything was peaceful,” he said, and the exhausted skipper, Cmdr. Thomas Burrowes, had just gone to his state room for a much needed rest.
Burrowes had already lost one ship, the USS O’Brien, to the Japanese the year before and was reluctant to leave the bridge.
“I got a responsibility here for every one of these kids’ mothers to bring them back home again,” Weathers recalled him saying.
“I was very touched by that,” he said. “But he went down into his cabin, and about thirty minutes later, ‘Bam!’ ”
“We’d been doing figure eights, about three, four miles long,” he said in a telephone interview Tuesday. “We’d been doing that for a day and a half and were becoming relaxed because there was no report of anything.”
Scores of sailors were asleep in the aft compartments.
When the mine went off, “the whole ship came out of the water,” Weathers, of Seal Beach, Calif., said. A huge flash appeared on the radar screen.
Part of the stern was all but severed, and dangled by the starboard screw shaft for a few minutes before it broke free and sank. “If you took a cigar and hit it with a baseball bat and broke off the end, that’s the way it looked,” he said.
The crew went to battle stations. Weathers ran to his, an antiaircraft gun. But there was nothing to shoot at, so he started helping rescue men who had fallen into the frigid water.
“It was kind of a bad thing,” he said. The sea was coated with fuel oil. “Everybody was so slippery, you couldn’t get a hold of anybody.”
The rescuers used life jackets to hook men in the water and then haul them in. “We pulled up a few,” he said. But “they didn’t last too long in the cold water. … You weren’t good for more than 10 or 15 minutes.”
Seventy-one men were lost, the Navy said. Weathers said he knew most of them. The entire crew numbered about 330.
The blast had also set off the ship’s smokescreen mechanism, which was belching toxic smoke and choking survivors.
The Abner Read was now powerless, and adrift near the shore. Plus, there might be other mines in the area.
Another destroyer managed to tow the ship out of danger.
The vessel was later towed to Bremerton, Wash., where it got a new stern and was returned to the war.
On Nov. 1, 1944, the Abner Read was struck by the suicide plane and sank in about 30 minutes. All but 20 members of the crew were rescued. Weathers was burned but survived.
The depth of discovery
The multi-beam sonar scans of the flat sea floor west of Kiska on July 17 had quickly picked up an object. Pietruszka and the other scientists aboard the research ship Norseman II spotted it right away. This had to be it.
They sent down an underwater robot with cameras, and there, looming out of the dim light, was the encrusted profile of the Abner Read’s sunken five-inch gun.
“It’s like scoring a touchdown,” Pietruszka said. “You see it come on the screen, and the whole room goes pretty nuts.”
But things soon got quiet.
“It’s a very humbling experience,” he said. “To be part of, even without the recovery of these remains, families can find some solace that somebody found where their loved one is, that you can put that to rest.”
An earlier version of this story incorrectly reported that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) said the battle between Japan and U.S. in the Aleutian Islands was the only World War II battle on North American soil. The story also erred in reporting that NOAA asserted that the islands of Kiska and Attu are the only U.S. territories to be occupied by foreign forces in the last 200 years. The agency said Kiska was one of only two United States territories to be occupied by foreign forces in the last 200 years.