The thread went viral, but many people have since criticized the thread as an invasion of privacy. So on Tuesday Blair tweeted an apology, saying “the last thing I want to do is to remove agency and autonomy from another woman.” She apologizes for “utilizing what could have been a beautiful charming moment among strangers as a tool to communicate a narrative I am fond of.”
During her thread, Blair scratched out the pair’s faces so that they weren’t identifiable, showing Blair’s and her boyfriend’s giddy faces instead. The incremental updates on how the conversation was progressing, who was nudging closer to whom and how they left the plane continuing to chat became a viral thread that inspired ohhs and ahhs — and hundreds of thousands of retweets. In the following days, Holden went on the “Today” show and “Good Morning America” to talk about his meet-cute. Meanwhile, the woman he’d hit it off with — identified only as Helen — wished to remain out of the spotlight.
Some who initially retweeted the thread, thinking it was sweet, changed their minds once they heard what Helen had endured.
Writing in the Atlantic, Taylor Lorenz articulated the dangers in broadcasting strangers’ interactions without their consent: “What sounds like romantic banter to an eavesdropper could be a nightmare for one or both of the people involved,” Lorenz writes. “Blair repeatedly implies in her thread that Helen is flirting with Holden, but was she? Who is to say this woman wasn’t simply politely entertaining the man next to her for fear of being rude? Or perhaps she has a partner at home. She should be allowed to casually flirt or make a new friend without people on the internet suggesting that she had sex with a stranger in a plane bathroom.”
Even in her apology, however, Blair doesn’t seem quite ready to let this story go. “Helen – to you, I offer my services,” Blair writes. “In whatever way you wish to continue this story – it’s now yours, as it should have been the entire time.”