2. New York Mets
2016: 87-75, lost wild-card game to Giants
Significant additions: None
Significant losses: SP Bartolo Colon
Clubhouse catalyst: LF Yoenis Cespedes
The season is a success if: their starting pitching stays healthy. While this can generally be said of any team, the Mets rely on rotation health more than most, if only because at its best, their projected rotation of Noah Syndergaard, Jacob DeGrom, Steven Matz, Matt Harvey and Zack Wheeler is arguably the best in the game – and perhaps enough to push them past the Nationals in the East. But DeGrom, Matz and Harvey are all coming off various surgeries (with Harvey’s the most serious), and Wheeler is being brought along slowly after missing most of the past two seasons following his own surgery.
3. Atlanta Braves
Significant additions: SP Bartolo Colon, SP R.A. Dickey, SP Jaime Garcia, 2B Brandon Phillips, IF Sean Rodriguez
Significant losses: SP/RP John Gant, SP/RP Tyrell Jenkins, RP Eric O’Flaherty, OF Mallex Smith, RP Chris Withrow, C A.J. Pierzynski
Clubhouse catalyst: 1B Freddie Freeman
The season is a success if: they manage to field a solid team in their first season in a new suburban stadium while still seeing progress from their young core. The Braves went 40-36 from July 6 through the end of the 2016 season, carried largely by youngsters such as Freeman, shorstop Dansby Swanson, centerfielder Ender Inciarte and starting pitchers Julio Teheran and Mike Foltynewicz, which led the front office to add some veteran pieces this winter in hopes of making an out-of-nowhere charge in 2017. But in the big picture, this season is about giving the top-rated farm system in baseball (via Baseball America) another year of maturation and assembling the pieces around Swanson – a consensus top-five prospect who looks like a franchise player – for a title run in 2018 and beyond.
4. Miami Marlins
Significant additions: SP Edinson Volquez, RP Brad Ziegler, SP Dan Straily, C A.J. Ellis, SP Jeff Locke
Significant losses: SP Andrew Cashner, RP Mike Dunn, RP Fernando Rodney
Clubhouse catalyst: RF Giancarlo Stanton
The season is a success if: they don’t collapse under the weight of losing ace Jose Fernandez. The charismatic Cuban right-hander died last September in a boating accident off Miami Beach, a loss the Marlins barely had time to process before the season ended. The tragedy has both a profound emotional component, and a practical one: The Marlins have to replace the unreplaceable, an ace who won 16 games with a 2.86 ERA last year. The additions of Volquez, Straily and Locke, the last of whom will start the year on the disabled list, should help with depth. But even taken together, they don’t equal Fernandez.
5. Philadelphia Phillies
Significant additions: OF Howie Kendrick, OF Michael Saunders, SP Clay Buchholz, RP Joaquin Benoit, RP Pat Neshek
Significant losses: 1B Ryan Howard, OF Peter Bourjos, RP David Henderson, LF Cody Asche
Clubhouse catalyst: C Cameron Rupp
The season is a success if: their lengthy rebuild turns a corner. The buyout of Howard’s contract symbolized a clean break from the successes (and excesses) of the last great Phillies era, and there is the outline of a solid core here, with five members of the starting lineup and three members of the starting rotation ages 27 or younger. There’s plenty more on the way, too, starting with top shortstop prospect J.P. Crawford, who could be in Philly by midseason.
But clearly, the front office had enough concerns to feel the need to hedge this winter, in the form of a slew of veteran acquisitions to plug gaps. The Phillies have few long-term financial commitments, and could be huge players in the vaunted free agent class of 2018. But it would help the long-term vision if they could see real progress on the field in 2017.
Coming soon: AL East (later Monday), AL and NL Central (Tuesday), AL and West (Weds.)
Fancy Stats: The Cubs’ youth puts a dynasty within reach