The letter is a response to President Trump’s executive order in January on “Enhancing Public Safety in the Interior of the United States,” which called for increased use of the “287 g” deputization of local law enforcement to perform immigration checks and threatened to withhold federal grant money from sanctuary cities and counties.
The letter, first reported by the Guardian, is not addressed to the president but rather to members of the Senate, and is signed by the chiefs of Orlando, Houston, Boston, Seattle, Salt Lake City and Los Angeles County as well as smaller jurisdictions such as Marshalltown, Iowa, and Garden City, Kan.
“We believe,” the letter states, “that we can best serve our communities by leaving the enforcement of immigration laws to the federal government. Threatening the removal of valuable grant funding from jurisdictions that choose not to spend limited resources enforcing federal immigration law is extremely problematic. Removing these funds … would not fix any part of our broken immigration system.”
The letter discusses issues similar to those raised in January by the U.S. Conference of Mayors, representing more than 1,400 cities with populations over 30,000, and the Major Cities Chiefs Association, which represents 63 large police departments. It notes that “federal court decisions … have found federal immigration detainers violate the constitution” because they are not criminal warrants, which causes many departments and jails to release undocumented immigrants from custody even if an immigration detainer has been filed for them.
The letter also pointed out that “there is no set definition of what comprises a ‘sanctuary jurisdiction’ and the term is often defined much too broadly.”
The letter emerged after members of the chiefs’ immigration task force met with members of Congress in early February, according to J. Thomas Manger, chief of the Montgomery County, Md., police and head of the Major Cities Chiefs. “We just wanted to make our position clear,” Manger said Wednesday. “We do believe we should be working with ICE [Immigration and Customs Enforcement] and identifying folks in our community who are dangerous.”
Law enforcement executives met with members of Congress, and Manger met with House Speaker Paul D. Ryan (R-Wis.). “I was encouraged by the conversation we had with him,” Manger said. “I think he’s fairly supportive of what we were talking about.”
Chiefs and sheriffs with larger immigrant populations “have to be concerned about the fear and the panic in the immigrant community,” because of their unwillingness to cooperate with authorities, which in turn makes them more vulnerable as crime targets, Manger said. The letter says that compelling state and local law enforcement “to carry out new and sometimes problematic tasks undermines the delicate federal balance and will harm locally-based community-oriented policing.”
Manger said, “I believe we can help influence this to go in a direction that’s better than the extremists who say, ‘Deport them all.’ ”
Here is the letter from the Law Enforcement Immigration Task Force: