Five players, including John Wall and Bradley Beal, logged at least 38 minutes in the double-overtime loss.
The Pacers are fighting for a playoff spot, and while the Wizards have nothing on the line, they would like to keep Indiana out of the postseason.
The Bulls' win over the Nets Monday ensured that the Wizards can't climb to the fourth seed in the East, but gives them a better idea who they may play.
Washington looks to end its three-game skid against a healthier Indiana team in what should be a physical contest.
The Pacers cut the Wizards' 22-point lead to three before falling, 97-90.
The Wizards (4-2) will look to extend the Pacers' losing streak to six games Saturday night at Bankers Life Fieldhouse.
Hibbert shot 0 of 7 from the floor.
The Wizards (3-1) and Pacers (1-3) meet for the first time since Indiana eliminated Washington from the playoffs last season.
The backup big man wants to send a message to the team that eliminated Washington from last season's playoffs: "If you’re going to beat us you’re going to have to leave some blood on the ground."
Butler will have the chance to compete for the final spot on the Wizards roster.