The wisdom on this isn't necessarily wrong, but the Hopkins research suggests it's incomplete. Rather than doing the same thing over and over, you might be able to learn things even faster — like, twice as fast — if you change up your routine. Practicing your baseball swing? Change the size and weight of your bat. Trying to nail a 12-bar blues in A major on the guitar? Spend 20 minutes playing the blues in E major, too. Practice your backhand using tennis rackets of varying size and weight.
"What we found is if you practice a slightly modified version of a task you want to master, you actually learn more and faster than if you just keep practicing the exact same thing multiple times in a row," said Pablo Celnik, an author on the study, in a statement.
Here's how they arrived at that conclusion. The researchers recruited 86 healthy volunteers and asked them to learn how to perform an abstract motor task that involved moving a cursor across a screen by squeezing an object connected to the computer. "The screen test featured five windows and a 'home space,' " according to a release describing the study. "Participants were asked to move the cursor from home to the various windows in a set pattern as quickly and accurately as possible."
Essentially, the recruits had to learn how to use a mouse that operated via squeezing, rather than sliding around.
The subjects were separated into three groups. All three groups participated in an initial testing session. Then, two of the groups did a follow-up exercise six hours later. The first group performed the exact same test as before. The second group did a six-hour follow-up too, but their test was different. The rules were similar — move a cursor around by squeezing something — but the researchers subtly altered the test by changing the amount of force required to use the cursor.
A third group, serving as a control, didn't perform any six-hour followup.
Finally, all three groups performed the initial test again, 24 hours after it was first taken. The question: Which group would perform best, showing the greatest increase in ability to move the cursor?
The control group — the ones who didn't do a six-hour follow-up session — performed the worst. The group that repeated the exact same test six hours later did considerably better.
But the folks who did the variation of the test at six hours performed best of all — 24 hours after the initial session they scored nearly twice as high on the task as the group that did the same test at six hours.
"For skills to improve, we must update an existing memory with new information," the researchers conclude. If you practice the exact same thing the exact same way every time, you're not layering much new knowledge over what you already know.
But, the theory goes, subtly changing things up and adding tension between what your body already knows and what it doesn't can help you learn skills faster.
The researchers caution that it's important not to change things up too much. If you're trying to improve your golf swing and spend 20 minutes a day shooting hoops, you're probably not doing yourself any favors. "If you make the altered task too different, people do not get the gain we observed," Celnik said. "The modification between sessions needs to be subtle."