Berlin-based newspaper B.Z. called the video “absurd, populist,” and its competitor Berliner Morgenpost referred to it as a “gaga video.” On Twitter, the video was mocked by commentators calling it “ridiculous” and describing how they first checked whether it had been produced for a comedy show.
Germans are likely to have a few objections. Trying to illustrate refugees living in train stations in the country, the video's producers picked a sequence of an arriving Austrian train, for instance. (To some Germans, worse than calling the country an Islamic State might be the suggestion that it is part of Austria.) Viewers might also wonder about the decision to feature a map highlighting exactly three European cities: Berlin, Paris — and Nantes, a city with roughly 300,000 inhabitants in western France.
The Morgenpost newspaper described the video as an effort to influence the U.S. election campaign in favor of Donald Trump although its producers denied such claims, speaking to the newspaper. Secure America Now, the neoconservative group behind the video, states that it wants to bring “critical security issues to the forefront of the American debate,” according to its website. The group also has more than 3 million fans on Facebook.
Although the video has been widely perceived to be pro-Trump in Germany, its producers have suggested that its main goal is to influence Senate races in several states.
Throughout his campaign, however, Trump has repeatedly criticized Germany's decision to take in hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees. In August, he called it a “disaster.”
“In short, Hillary Clinton wants to be America’s Angela Merkel,” Trump said, “and you know what a disaster this massive immigration has been to Germany and the people of Germany — crime has risen to levels that no one thought they would ever see. We have enough problems in our country, we don’t need another one.”
German officials had previously disputed such claims. “Immigrants are not more criminal than Germans,” a ministry spokesman was quoted as saying.